4 ms·
I'll answer this with the plot for the movie 3:10 to Yuma. Rain falls down from the sky. It goes through a river. The river passes through Glen Hollander's lan
by peterwwillis 13y ago
I'll answer this with the plot for the movie 3:10 to Yuma.
Rain falls down from the sky. It goes through a river. The river passes through Glen Hollander's land before it ends up in your backyard. Glen realizes this, and puts up a dam to prevent the water from reaching you, unless you pay a monthly fee.
You may not like it, but the internet is the rain, and it's flowing through Comcast's land before it gets to your back yard. You can always try to find a different landowner to sell you water if you don't like it, but ain't no "argument" that's gonna change where the rain falls. (Unless you start your own ILEC and dig your own fiber)
- mpyne 13y agoCareful with that though. You're creeping pretty close to some of the more absurd thought exercises of a pure libertarian utopia, the types of thought exercises that show pure libertarianism to be flawed as a universal sociopolitical scheme. In the actual U.S. it is entirely probable that Glen would be made to get rid of the dam instead of cutting off water supply to the rest of the county, for the same underlying common-sense principles that have caused things like easements to end up in property law.
- burntsushi 13y agoI must have missed the meeting where libertarians decided that a free society would be a utopia.
- peterwwillis 13y agoYes, it's likely that an actual water supply could be a target for an easement, mainly because it's the only method of either transportation or sustaining someone's livelihood/life in a desert climate. Even if the internet 'needed' to be used, the only easement you could claim would be on the equipment of the telco in order to access something over the telco's property [that you could not otherwise access]. There are multiple methods to gain internet access, and the internet is not a requirement of a property or method of access (unless telephones and postal mail become abolished), and does not affect your property. I don't see what any of this has to do with political philosophy. The law is the law; doesn't much matter what you label it.
- diminoten 13y agoWhat if I helped build Glen's dam, because Glen convinced me that without the dam, the river would dry up before it got to me, and I'd be out of water? What if Glen tricked everyone into not building dams of their own, because Glen promised to let other people use his water too, but then didn't actually honor his promise?