12 ms·
I don't know why the US hasn't adopted EMV. It's not perfect, but it has cut down fraud massively here in Europe. They're very hard to clone (I won't say impos
by Nursie 13y ago
I don't know why the US hasn't adopted EMV. It's not perfect, but it has cut down fraud massively here in Europe.
They're very hard to clone (I won't say impossible, but attacks against EMV have not generally been of this nature) and the transaction records at both ends will tell you whether the actual, real card was there.
The liability is more clear-cut as a result. If the customer claims the charge was unauthorised, that's between the bank and the customer.
--edit-- of course with EMV cards Coin would no longer be possible or relevant. Neat product, only useful in a magnetic-stripe world, which is at least a decade behind the curve now.
Theoretically with EMV you could put all your credit-cards on one chip and the terminal will either choose a supported default or present you a list, but that would require cross-bank cooperation, never going to happen.
- pbreit 13y agoBecause it's a massive cost for almost no gain.
- huhtenberg 13y agoDo elaborate on "no gain".
- pbreit 13y agoA few basis points.
- huhtenberg 13y agoYou'll have to dumb it down, I have no idea what this means.
- Nursie 13y agoErrr, did you read the part where fraud has dropped massively? And liability is more clear-cut and reasonable for pretty much all parties? --edit-- and did you think us Europeans just rolled it out for shits and giggles?
- foobarqux 13y ago> And liability is more clear-cut and reasonable for pretty much all parties? Meaning shifted entirely to the consumer?
- Nursie 13y agoNo, the merchant takes reasonable liability - if they permit non-EMV transactions (in a customer-present scenario) they assume the risk. Under law in much of Europe, the consumer is not under much risk. In the UK (for example) the credit card provider is legally a party to the debt and has a responsibility to refund the consumer on demand if the consumer is willing to state (in a legally binding way) that the transaction was not authorised by them. Debit cards are governed by different rules that amount to much the same, though the legal protections are weaker.
- PeterisP 13y agoEU law shifts pretty much all liability away from consumer. There's a cap of EUR 150 consumer liability for lost&stolen (physically) cards up until you notify the bank; zero liability for lost&stolen cards after the time of notification, and zero liability for any fraudulent transactions if your card isn't lost or stolen. Only UK law (and MC/Visa rules for UK) is a bit different, but another poster describes them below.
- zmk_ 13y agoPlus depending on whether the terminal allowed chip and pin, and the card had a chip the liability is shifted between the merchant and the bank.
- fps 13y agoCredit card fraud is generally not a problem in the US for consumers or the credit card companies, the two groups that would be in a position to adopt a new credit card technology. The merchants accept all the liability in the US credit card system, and they're at the mercy of the credit card company's policies, and the consumer's desire to use their card of choice or go somewhere else. As a consumer, I avoid cash-only businesses, and even tend to frequent ones that accept my card of choice (Discover) over those that only accept the cheaper cards (Visa/MC.) Businesses know this, and they're willing to accept credit cards so that they can earn most people's business.
- r00fus 13y agoif by that you mean no gain to the financial institutions who get a cut whether fraud happens or not, they yeah. No big gain for them = not happening.
- virtuz 13y agoApart from the security. Coin shows just how easy it is to skim and duplicate cards. Way more difficult with chip and pin.
- sentenza 13y agoI don't know about the US, but professional swipe-card fraud is something that the average European will typically have read about in their local newspaper by now. It is extremely common.
- huhtenberg 13y ago@virtuz - you are hell-banned Ref: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6735258 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6735258
- virtuz 13y agoHuh, what for?
- busterarm 13y agoI want chip and pin cards SO BADLY here. Mainly because it would make my trips to Europe a lot easier, where many systems I've encountered won't work on some non-EMV cards.
- liyanchang 13y agoChase Sapphire Preferred offers EMV cards[0] and no foriegn exchange charges. Makes a good travel card. [0] Technically: chip-and-signature rather then chip-and-pin. Also, you have to ask for the EMV but they're super friendly about it.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI've found my chip and signature Amex Platinum Card to be just as useless in Europe as my old magstrip-only card.
- makomk 13y agoThat's surprising; chip and signature exists in part for accessibility reasons and everywhere is meant to accept them.
- busterarm 13y agoI had a really tough time with credit cards in Denmark. I had one chip & sig card that didn't work except in like one restaurant I went to. A couple of places I could use any regular credit card though. Ended up having to go to ATMs and carry cash, which is so uncommon that people think you're a drug dealer. :D
- freshrap6 13y agoBank of America has a similar one too, and it doesn't have a yearly fee.
- encoderer 13y ago
- rmc 13y agoAmericans going to Europe: Remember that your credit card might not work as often in Europe. Be prepared for hearing "We only take chip & pin cards here" in shops etc.
- delive 13y agoI've had the same issue in the past which can be frustrating (though now I always travel with enough cash). I actually called Visa about it and they told me that any vendor accepting Visa transactions is required by their contract with Visa to accept swipe transactions. She said it was there because the US was still rolling out chip and pin cards.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoImagine my dismay when a coffeeshop in Amsterdam would not take my magstrip only American Express.
- mrinterweb 13y agoThe different scenarios my imagination has come up with all end with you saying "mega bummer, dude".
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI paid with cash in the end :) A+, would do again.
- aioprisan 13y agoamex cards all have chip versions that you can request for free
- toomuchtodo 13y agoHave the chip version of the Amex Platinum. Since its the US version, its chip and signature, not chip and pin, and works almost nowhere in Europe.
- freshhawk 13y agoAs I Canadian I also read this with a little sadness. It's something I have always wanted ... but now someone made it just as we're close to finishing the transition to EMV. It can actually be a bit tricky to use my company card to buy lunch at restaurants sometimes because "there's no chip". Their FAQ says future versions of Coin will support EMV, but I'm not familiar enough with the hardware to know how difficult that is. Would be good for those stupid loyalty/membership cards I guess, if you are good with explaining what the hell this weird card looking thing is and why it will work like the normal cards every single damn time you use it.
- Nursie 13y agoThe EMV transaction process has "application selection" as one of its early stages, and some cards do contain multiple applications. However AFAICT this is never across banks or across schemes. So you may get a card that has (say) a Mastercard application on it for domestic use and another for foreign use. In theory, you could slam mastercard, visa, amex, credit, debit, whatever else you want, all on the one chip. Depending on the exact card and terminal implementation a transaction would either use the default application or get an on-screen display asking you which you would like to use. But you'd have to get the banks to load the app on there as there are sensitive keys involved. That's not exactly the same as Coin - you couldn't pre-select which card to use in which situation, and you couldn't load them yourself. I suppose in theory you could have multiple EMV chips on a card like Coin and have a circuit-switching arrangement of some sort. There would need to be a way to embed them there and that would put a limit on things... --edit-- about the stupid loyalty card things - in Australia I noticed most of them had started working on barcodes, and people had smartphone apps that gave them a menu and displayed the right code, pretty cool.
- bdamm 13y agoThere are three tricks involved with this. One, you may not be able to download the card app from one card and upload it to another. My GlobalCard fu is not well honed enough to tell you what ADPU you'd need to invoke in order to try, but it goes against the goals of the product to allow this anyway. Two, if a credit card company provides you with an EMV card, it's got a private key loaded into the card, and may have even originally been generated on the card. It is outright not allowed under any circumstance to download that private key and upload it to another chip; that would be a major hole in the scheme. Three, not all banks use the same crypto. Even if they all agreed to a single kind of crypto operation, different EMV chips have different performance characteristics when carrying out crypto operations. If the bank can't control the actual EMV chip any more, then they cannot control elements of their payments processing (e.g. session closure within a certain time frame). This problem is the easiest to solve of these three problems. So, unless the banks get on board with allowing their apps and their keys to be provisioned on an already existing card, or provide some kind of proxy mechanism whereby an EMV card can delegate another card to act on its behalf (and imagine the security concerns with that) then this isn't going to happen. I don't see the benefit to the banks for doing this. You're far more likely to see paypal succeeding in turning your phone into your wallet (and they are doing it) then you are to see Visa or MC allowing you to link multiple EMV cards into one.
- timfrietas 13y agoMy American card has a chip. It is rolling out here.
- outworlder 13y agoAs a Brazilian, I think the US banks are very strange. "Swipe" cards have been phased out years ago - you'd have to try hard to find a bank which will still issue one. Specifically because you can no longer find ATMs which rely solely on the magstripe. Some banks have biometric fingerprint readers (where you put in your hand and it reads multiple fingerprints at the same time) in addition to the PIN code of the debit/credit card, and sometimes additional passwords. My bank does not rely on biometrics, but in order to do any transactions, I have to enter a code generated by the bank which consists of three strings, which are prompted one at a time, displayed on screen mixed with other random and unrelated strings, so that someone peeking over my shoulder would not be able to match the button with what's on screen and finally, before the transaction is complete, the account's password. And that's with a chip. The portable readers you can find everywhere still have magstripe readers in addition to the chip reader and will refuse to read the magnetic strip if the card contains a chip. Those portable readers use either a 3g connection or standard dialup. As for the physical "imprints", this is something that 30-somethings like me can barely remember. Also related: there are no bills which can't be paid online. All banks accept them, unless specified otherwise (usually there are restriction after the expiry date). If you get a bill by mail (instead of email), you can just type the barcode. Or scan it, if you have a reader or a mobile phone with the bank's app. The concept of getting bills by mail, and then mailing back cheques, as found in the US, is completely alien.
- dgallagher 13y agoVery interesting, thanks for sharing. You hit on something though; in the U.S. there are tens of thousands of ATM machines all over. They all accept PIN numbers, and I "believe" magnetic-strip as well (not sure if they're doing fancy stuff too with built-in chips or not). It's the standard that everyone uses; debit card and credit cards alike. To change that to support different tech, you'd have to upgrade all of the ATM machines, all of the credit cards, and all of the backend tech. That's a lot of coordination between banks/credit-card companies. On top of that you have POS systems in stores which are all magnetic-strip based as well, accepting PINs and/or signatures. Any sort of switch would have to be phased-in over years and require a lot of buy-in. Unless retailers, banks, ATM providers, and credit card companies have a good business case to do so, they probably won't. I'd imagine it would be easier for some other type of technology which displaces cards entirely, like phone-based payments, would eventually replace all of this. An idea like Coin augments the current "archaic" system and has the potential to take off. But outside of the U.S. it sounds like it won't work without modification.
- revelation 13y agoSo that's why this video was so confusing to me. It was essentially this guy sliding someones card (he claims it's his, but neither the device nor the card know, right?) and then happily paying stuff with it through his fake replica (or the high-tech version of it, the 'coin'). It seemed like a completely unusable system for it's complete lack of any security. (Particularly if you consider there are now live payment systems that use pretty much the same audio jack serial port hack as this one does to clone cards)
- jakethehuman 13y agoI would assume it would be like any other credit card transaction: up to the merchant to verify the account holder with an ID. The fraud you're speaking of is not limited to this technology; anyone could find and use a credit card they found on the ground if the merchant did not verify it.
- umsm 13y agoTheoretically, the creators of coin can implement some sort of security in these sorts of situations: 1) They require you to register this "coin" device 2) They require you to add some banking account details Now, if you were to "clone" someone else's card without their permission, the trail would lead directly to you...
- sopooneo 13y agoThat brings up an off-topic point I've always wondered about. If apple will not make it possible for third party devices to interface with the iPhone through the normal port, why do approve apps that rely on hardware using the audio jack this way?
- steven2012 13y agoEMV where you need to input a PIN Number is simply a way for VISA/MC to push all the liability onto the customers for stolen credit cards. If a purchase is made with the credit card and PIN, then the issuing bank can simply let the liability fall on the customer, instead of the bank eating the costs, like how it's done today.
- ahlatimer 13y agoThe banks don't eat the costs -- the merchants do.
- Tomdarkness 13y agoIn the UK at least this is not true. The bank have to demonstrate you did not take reasonable care to protect your PIN (e.g you left it written down in your wallet). See some of the following case studies by the FOS that support the fact that the customer is not always liable even if the PIN is used: http://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications/ombudsman-news/89/89-banking-complaints.htm http://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/publications/ombudsman...
- Nursie 13y agoMerchants eat the costs where no EMV card was used. Customers eat some costs where the bank can prove negligence, and face court if the bank can prove fraud (i.e. signed statement it wasn't you but later the CCTV footage is found. Oops) Other than that, here in Europe, customers are protected by law from having to take on the liability. Varies by country, but basically it's a case of "you're responsible to see that nobody else gets to take my money, that's why you're a bank numbnuts"
- bloopletech 13y agoIn Australia, we've even moved beyond EMV; the majority of merchants now accept Visa PayWave and MasterCard PayPass for tap-and-go. [edit: Oh, and all my debit/credit cards are now paywave/paypass enabled, and they are all from the big 4/5 banks] The Coin page doesn't mention this at all; does it have this? If not, it sounds like a step backwards.
- brotchie 13y agoI was thinking the same thing. A full 60% of MasterCard and Visa transaction are now paywave/paypass. That's pretty impressive uptake, and I'd imagine it will be just as quick one introduced en-mass overseas. Would love to know Coin's development path for this eventuality! "Australia leads the world in contactless payments, which have grown from almost zero three years ago to more than 35 million transactions a month and now account for 60 per cent of all MasterCard and Visa credit card transactions, according to Westpac." http://www.theland.com.au/news/agriculture/agribusiness/general-news/coles-new-way-to-pay/2675249.aspx http://www.theland.com.au/news/agriculture/agribusiness/gene...
- nevster 13y agoIt's times like this that show how backwards the US is in many things. The whole time I was watching the video, I was thinking "Huh - who swipes their card any more?!"
- Nursie 13y agoI don't think they have a path for this. Getting the bank to hand over the keys needed will be next to impossible.
- Nursie 13y agoI'll let you in on a little secret - paywave/paypass etc are EMV cards. The interface is wireless and they have a shorter transaction flow. There are less (zero) customer validation techniques, final evaluation (pass/fail) takes place at the stage a 'normal' EMV transaction would decide on pass/online/fail. As usual there are variations between implementations, but underneath it's all good-ol' EMV :) So I doubt that these could be supported easily by Coin, it requires various keys that the banks do not allow to escape. If Coin do manage to get talking to banks about allowing wired or wireless EMV apps to be loaded onto a customer Coin card then that would be awesome. I predict that layers of bureaucracy and brand-management will prevent this. But good luck to 'em if they try!
- tpurves 13y agoThe US is shifting to EMV at merchants by 2015, see: http://corporate.visa.com/newsroom/press-releases/press1142.jsp http://corporate.visa.com/newsroom/press-releases/press1142....
- Mister_Snuggles 13y agoCanada has adopted EMV very quickly. Within only a few years, I went from swiping everything to swiping almost nothing.
- vacri 13y agoThis is a total stab in the dark from a foreigner, but I though that it was only recently that US banks could be larger than a state-level entity. My entirely uneducated guess would be that with only state-level banks, none of them would have the pure muscle to push something as big as this.
- rcoh 13y agoThe US hasn't adopted EMV because it isn't necessary. EMV was created because in Eastern Europe many businesses didn't have sufficiently reliable phone and internet connections to validate credit cards -- in the US we have no such problem. The cost of rolling out EMV was determined to be greater than the cost credit card companies paying for the increase in fraud and chargebacks out of pocket.
- btbuilder 13y agoI'm not sure about this logic considering one of the earliest adopters of EMV was the UK.
- vidarh 13y agoPretty much every major US bank has committed to rolling out EMV by middle of 2015.
- rsynnott 13y ago> EMV was created because in Eastern Europe many businesses didn't have sufficiently reliable phone and internet connections to validate credit cards The first large chip and pin deployment was in France, in 1992. At the time, Eastern Europe was in economic chaos, and not really on the radar.
- toadi 13y agoFor Debit cards payment scheme's are already joined on 1 EMV chip. The terminal configuration decides which one is used. To join issuers on 1 card I agree cross-bank cooperation will never happen. Credit cards are divided by payment scheme's. Banks just issue cards for 1 of the scheme's eg. Mastercard or VISA, ... don't think Mastercard. In this field I don't think Mastercard will want their competitor on the same card. Even technically it's not so easy to implement for a payment processor (I work for a payment processor).