3 ms·
No, it just requires understanding something about the nature of mathematics and its relationship with reality. You can't prove the existence of god any more th
by leephillips 13y ago
No, it just requires understanding something about the nature of mathematics and its relationship with reality. You can't prove the existence of god any more than you can prove the existence of gravity. To make the connection between the math and reality requires interpretation, as Einstein repeatedly pointed out.
Gödel's amusing exercise is just a formalization of St. Anselm's, and most of the centuries of criticism of the latter can be applied to the former. In particular, his little proof has three definitions and six special-purpose axioms, and, in addition to all this, depends on a property of goodness or perfection that is only defined implicitly. Naturally, the existence of something that he interprets as "god" falls out as a theorem. Big deal.
The nature of mathematics are that the theorems are contained within the axioms. If the axioms are self-evident, and the conclusions are surprising, we have some interesting math. But at least two of Gödel's axioms are not self-evident. Therefore, this "proof" strikes me as a setup, and is not very interesting.
- cscurmudgeon 13y agoThe same can be said for anything in life. I really hope you wake up everyday praying that the laws of physics hold today because there is no proof that will hold today. If you claim that goodness is artificial/relative/subjective, then you are hilariously self-refuting yourself. :) http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/relativism/#5.9 http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/relativism/#5.9
- leephillips 13y agoWell, you fooled me. I thought you were serious and might know what you were talking about.
- cscurmudgeon 13y ago>I thought you were serious and might know what you were talking about. Thanks for the kind mature words. You are no different from the Christian fundamentalists who accuse that the scientists (including logicians like me) don't know what they are talking about. Sigh. I was being respectful, but you showed your deficiency by attacking my intellect. Thanks for that. I can only point in the right direction. I cannot rectify a highly deficient education (ah, the US).
- Anderkent 13y agoThat's obviously a strawman. A relative morality doesn't claim that 'truth' is relative, it claims that the concepts of 'good' (morally acceptable) and 'bad' are relative. Thus when saying morality is relative it's not that we say that the factuality of "X is moral" depends on your setting, but that the statement makes no sense unless you specify what morality you mean, because "moral" just means "acceptable in a given morality system".