3 ms·
Consider that copyright originated as system with which to control people. The types of control sought were those of monetary, and thought/expression of thought
by peterwwillis 13y ago
Consider that copyright originated as system with which to control people. The types of control sought were those of monetary, and thought/expression of thought.
Monetary control goes back to antiquity, where copying a book required expensive literate slaves to copy a book for about the same price as publishing one. Thought and expression control goes back to the censorship systems of the church, who sought to prevent critical dissent via restricting publishing using licenses - later termed a "monopoly".
These two systems were then combined in practice. Not only were the printers/publishers restricted and licensed, but what they could print or reprint as well. This control over what was published not only served the church and/or state's interests in enforcing dogmatic or state law, but also the monetary interests of the original publishers of a work. In essence, the publisher and the government form a pact to ensure each other's mutual interests, at the expense of the common citizen.
It wasn't until 1710 that the game changed. The Statute of Anne ushered in not only the destruction of publishing monopolies, but the argument (in form of law) that "protecting" a work from copying was primarily an incentive for scholars to keep churning out more works - the argument summarized as: "Why would learned men compose and write useful books unless there was financial incentive?" Flash forward to today, and that's basically still the same argument used by anyone lobbying for copyright of anything. If it's copied and nobody gets paid, nobody will make anything [intellectual/creative/etc] anymore.
Consider how amazingly specious this argument is today. Look at Wikipedia. Look at YouTube. Look at all the works being published under all the subversive licenses that are intended to surmount the aged limitations of copyright law. Do we really care to restrict what content you can produce, or if someone gets paid for it? More and more the arguments are about simple attibution, or freedom of use, than anything else.
All this decision finds is that the copying of books is by and of itself no longer a harmful act. But we've known that for decades.
- res0nat0r 13y agoThe ruling doesn't allow wholesale display of said books on books.google.com though.
- peterwwillis 13y ago.....So?
- res0nat0r 13y agoSo I hope you aren't implying above that this ruling states that is now legal.
- peterwwillis 13y agoNope.