3 ms·
> In the answers I do not see any mention of the Second Time Around Problem, which conclusively answers the question with "there is no way to know". No it does
by ars 13y ago
> In the answers I do not see any mention of the Second Time Around Problem, which conclusively answers the question with "there is no way to know".
No it doesn't. You are assuming the existence of a recording device, and worse excluding the recording device from your definition of universe.
> Then make a deterministic universe that just plays back the recording (this is the "second time around").
What does play back even mean in this context? When you play back a recording the events in it do not actually occur again. All you are doing is perusing a memory.
Your recoding doesn't even need to simulate the laws of physics - it simply places objects where they were - if you wanted to you could make any changes you like. So you could make the recording do anything. i.e. a recording is meaningless - it's not actually a universe. (By universe I mean something that follows a defined set of rules.)
> From the viewpoint of someone living inside the universe, there is no way to tell whether it is the first time around or the second time around.
In the the second time around they are not actually living in the universe.
> make a faraway point "go forward or backward in time"
No you can't. You can make it traverse time faster or slower, but you can not make it go forward and backward.
> The crazy thing is that for angular movements the relative speed is amplified by distance, so when you are moving around at everyday speeds the "now" on planets across the galaxy is going back and forth by thousands or millions of years.
That is simply not true. Angular movement has exactly zero effect on relativity - it's not true motion which requires a relative difference in energy (AKA speed).
- gtr32x 13y ago> (By universe I mean something that follows a defined set of rules.) I just want to make a mention for this point. Ahh but you see, for all we know, the universe could have simply followed 'a set of rules' up till the point we are living at and until a set future point in the 'timeline' (or something we perceive as the timeline). Then all of a sudden all the laws we know will break because the 'universe' entity decides to play another recording. Then all of knowledge of the 'universe' collapses. I think this is what the parent was talking about. You cannot predict nor even conclude that such scenario cannot happen.
- ars 13y agoIn that situation the universe is not following a defined set of rules, it is following an arbitrary set of rules. Even during the initial playback period.