2 ms·
As I understand "fair use", you have to admit to copyright violation(s) first. Fair use in the USA is a small carve-out of the exclusivity rights, for things li
by bediger4000 13y ago
As I understand "fair use", you have to admit to copyright violation(s) first. Fair use in the USA is a small carve-out of the exclusivity rights, for things like review, commentary, education, etc. The Wikipedia page on "fair use" says it's an affirmative defense (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_defense http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Affirmative_defense).
I also think you're confused about the moral basis for exclusive copyrights. The possible "benefits" for society are legally the only motivation for granting limited exclusive rights. Economically, monopolies (exclusive rights) are pretty bad all around, and politically, copyright is easily abused to stifle or chill free speech. We, as a society, put up with some odious side effects of copyright, in order to get people to produce more stuff now for general use later.
So, tell me why the Author's Guild don't get penalized for bringing a frivolous suit against Google - what google did is obviously for the best of society in general, and probably will be good for the authors in particular.