3 ms·
It was certainly true that in the US and the Soviet Union that the space program's primary "customer" was the military. It is an acceptable cover story to be "e
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
It was certainly true that in the US and the Soviet Union that the space program's primary "customer" was the military. It is an acceptable cover story to be "exploring space" when you are working on technologies that make for better ICBMs. And that was one of the interesting things about SpaceX to me, here was a company that didn't have some defense "minder" in the back rooms somewhere calling the shots.
The other thing that this reminded me of was that the history of the Arab world early on is one of excellent science and discovery. It would be nice to get back to that and away from what passes for state craft in the middle east. Sadly that seems like a harder problem than sending someone to the moon.
- masklinn 13y ago> It was certainly true that in the US and the Soviet Union that the space program's primary "customer" was the military. Not just in the US and Soviets, France's Diamant[0] was derived from its military "gemstones" sounding rockets program, the UK's Black Arrow originates from the Blue Streak MRBM program[1]. > It is an acceptable cover story to be "exploring space" when you are working on technologies that make for better ICBMs. And that was one of the interesting things about SpaceX to me I don't believe that's been the case for ISAS (now part of JAXA), it's unlikely the WWII peace treaty would have allowed for japanese ICBM development. [0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diamant http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diamant [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Streak_missile http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Streak_missile
- ChuckMcM 13y agoThere is some thought that the Epsilon [1] development was primarily a launch vehicle that could strike back at the PRK should they decide to do something. That thinking was motivated by the design criteria of 'solid fuel' (easy to store in a bunker, no delay in fueling it in responding) and 'minimal crew' (not like you can station 20 or 40 people at a missile bunker). Of course I have no insight into whether or not that was their thinking but folks I know who are part of the 'establishment' seem to think that is the rationale Japan used. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epsilon_%28rocket%29 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epsilon_%28rocket%29
- masklinn 13y agoEpsilon is a very recent project though, Japan has had rocket programs since the 60s (the Mu-1 sub-orbital test flight was in 1966)
- mturmon 13y agoWhile I'm not a historian of NASA (but see: http://history.nasa.gov/factsheet.htm http://history.nasa.gov/factsheet.htm), I think your summary in the first paragraph is way off. It's more accurate to say that the military had rockets in development, and they were pressed into service for the new space agency. From 1945 to 1957, the US military (Army, and later, Air Force) was sponsoring rocket development, e.g. von Braun's team in Huntsville. But after NASA was created in 1958 following Sputnik, it was made a civilian agency, and the crossover with the military was much less. NASA doesn't have a genuine connection to ICBMs. There's a lot more to space technology than rocketry, so there's little overlap between an ICBM (at the whole system level) and an earth-orbiter (again, considered as a system). For instance, one of the main ICBM design issues is target accuracy -- there's no such counterpart for an orbiter. Additionally, divergence between NASA goals and military goals is great enough that, even when prompted from above, the technology does not mix well. I'm thinking of the notion that the Shuttle would be used for military/intelligence satellite launch, and the NPOESS combined NOAA/NASA/DoD earth-observing satellite. The notion that there is a DoD "minder" in the back room seems kind of fanciful. In the late 1950s, maybe, but by the mid-60s -- I really doubt it -- except for some of the basic rocket engine technology.
- jlgreco 13y agoThe military's interest in rockets was not limited to lobbing warheads, they took a very early interest in using rockets to put things into orbit. The first US satellite, the Explorer 1, was kicked off by the Army and the first stage of the Juno rocket that launched it was a modified Redstone, an Army ballistic missile (not an ICBM). Skipping forward to manned flight, the first two US manned Mercury missions (1961) used extended Redstones again for sub-orbital launches. The next four Mercury missions (1962-1963) used modified Atlas rockets (Atlas LV-3B's specifically, which were man-rated Atlas D's) These Atlas rockets were America's first ICBMs. Atlas rockets continued to be used for space launches for several more years, launching target vehicles for docking with during Gemini, launching a few space probes, etc. Literally dozens of Atlas D ICBMs were used as launch vehicles for damn near half a century. Some of the first GPS satellites were put up on Atlas rockets. The Gemini missions (1965-1966) continued this tradition, all using man-rated Titan IIs (ICBMs, but with more redundancy for reliability). In the years that followed, the Titan II continued to be used for satellite launches, and like the Atlas, spawned a successful line of derivative launch vehicles. The point that I am making here is that ICBMs worked swimmingly as launch vehicles, and weren't just pushed onto NASA for a task that they weren't fit to perform. Slap a Centaur/Agena/etc on top and they can do a hell of a lot, and with a few added redundancies, they got men into space brilliantly. Redstones/Atlas's/Titan IIs made quality launch vehicles. We are by no means talking "minimal overlap". It wasn't until 1968, less than a year before putting a man on the moon, that NASA used a non-ICBM derived launch vehicle for a manned mission (The Saturn 1B, with Apollo 7, and a few short months later with the famous Saturn V, for Apollo 8).
- userulluipeste 13y ago«It was certainly true that in the US and the Soviet Union that the space program's primary "customer" was the military. It is an acceptable cover story to be "exploring space" when you are working on technologies that make for better ICBMs.» ...but that may only cover LEO at most. How about the programs involving the Moon and the other planets?