3 ms·
Who say that they are getting much joy or dignity or that they're doing it to further the wonder of capitalism or whatever strawman you made up? The difference
by kiba 17y ago
Who say that they are getting much joy or dignity or that they're doing it to further the wonder of capitalism or whatever strawman you made up?
The difference between a government's central planning and the company is that the company have to trade something to get anything done.
While the company may in fact central plan part of their operation, the fact is, the bricks must be traded for something else. The steel, the workers, and everything have to also occur by trade.
This is something that cannot happen by mere "central planning". Each individuals, must decide what will benefit them the most. After all, they could go do something else in the economy that need urgent attention.
- ubernostrum 17y ago"Who say that they are getting much joy or dignity or that they're doing it to further the wonder of capitalism or whatever strawman you made up?" Here's a direct quote from the article: "From the miners to the factory workers to the truck drivers to the smelters to the architects of the factories to the executives that run the companies that fund and organize each step of the process, each and every participant is in the game for his own self interest—to make a living, and to make a contribution that's really only a tiny part of the end result of a product, even one as insignificant as the humble pencil. Pan back until you've framed the entire world economy, and it's hard not to marvel at the wonder and miracle of capitalism's invisible hand." You want to tell me I'm making stuff up now? "The difference between a government's central planning and the company is that the company have to trade something to get anything done." "While the company may in fact central plan part of their operation, the fact is, the bricks must be traded for something else. The steel, the workers, and everything have to also occur by trade." "This is something that cannot happen by mere "central planning". Each individuals, must decide what will benefit them the most. After all, they could go do something else in the economy that need urgent attention." OK, you tell me: if you're the guy who lives in a slum in Bolivia and works for slave wage in a tin mine, to what other aspect of the economy can you devote your urgent attention? And, with the lowest GDP on the continent, what are you, your employer or your country getting in return for that resource to make it a worthwhile trade?
- kiba 17y ago"You want to tell me I'm making stuff up now?" EDIT: I see it now. I can see how you might interpret it as that. In any case, it is doubtful that people care about furthering the glory of capitalism. I think the author is talking about the invisible hand rather than any specific noble cause. "OK, you tell me: if you're the guy who lives in a slum in Bolivia and works for slave wage in a tin mine, to what other aspect of the economy can you devote your urgent attention? And, with the lowest GDP on the continent, what are you, your employer or your country getting in return for that resource to make it a worthwhile trade?" What? I don't understand your question. Surely the worker is mining tin so that he could eventually trade for food. The employer who are getting the tin can then eventually trade for something that they want, no? There's always attention to devote to in an economy. After all, there's always the never ending needs and wants that must be satisfied and the limited amount of resource that can be devoted toward the unsatisfiable demand of men. The question is not whether there's enough jobs but rather how the economy can reallocate resources correctly and efficently so that people can find work again. If the resource allocation remain uncorrected(Examples include overpaying for labor which often happen when minimum wage are enforced), parts of the population may continues unemployed although they may be able or skilled enough to trade their labor on the market.
- ubernostrum 17y agoIt's telling that your example of uncorrected problems is people being too well off. And, once again: you seem to think that people in places like Bolivian tin mines have options, that they can just move, or be moved, to something else at the drop of a hat. Reality ain't like that.
- anamax 17y ago> And, once again: you seem to think that people in places like Bolivian tin mines have options, that they can just move, or be moved, to something else at the drop of a hat. Reality ain't like that. The existence of a bad situation does not imply that a given solution will make things better. I note that hell-holes are usually associated with folks who are "doing things for the people". And, in point of fact, they can "just move", unless someone is pointing a gun at them. That someone is almost always a govt.