3 ms·
There's a big difference between terrorism security and both financial regulation and (especially) healthcare. In the former, CYA is actually the only thing th
by dasil003 17y ago
There's a big difference between terrorism security and both financial regulation and (especially) healthcare. In the former, CYA is actually the only thing that can be done. Of course no politician can ever say the truth, that when dealing with suicidal attackers there's really no way to even approach anything resembling comprehensive security--all our civil liberties and money would be spent well before we got there. Sane measures like regular police, intelligence actions, and refraining from jabbing political hornets' nests are just not going to be seen as enough by coddled middle America who remain blissfully ignorant of conditions in the rest of the world.
With healthcare, on the other hand, the problems of uncovered individuals and waste in the system are measurable and ongoing. Obviously there's no magical solution, but the problem can be attacked and the situation can be improved by a variety of metrics.
Financial regulation falls somewhere in between... even though those rich wall street cocksuckers totally screwed the rest of us and stole our money, it's not like they wanted this to happen. The problem of systemic risk in the financial system is something that you can bet thousands of the best minds in the private sector will be working on, and it's considerably more tractable than the issue of how you prevent all terrorist attacks.
- grandalf 17y agoI don't claim that terrorist attacks are not preventable. Flight 93 shows that the solution to preventing another 9/11 style attack was discovered the same day, on 9/11. Is there anything about the new financial regulations that actually reduces systemic risk? If anything, the government has sent a signal that big firms are "too big to fail" which ought to make them feel comfortable that if things go badly in the future they'll be bailed out again. This would seem to increase systemic risk, or at least reduce the incentives to mitigate it. As for healthcare, the real issue is nutrition -- the government tells us that we should eat lots of beef (by subsidizing its price) and other things that make us unhealthy and obese, and then the public demands things like cheaper prescription drugs to help with all the diseases related to obesity, heart disease, etc. So I'd say that at a broader level "health" is way more screwed up already than airline security or financial services. Politicians tell us that, for example, cheaper satins are the solution to the problem and that cardiologists make too much money. Could you ever imagine a politician telling the public to stop eating fast food, eat mostly fresh fruits and veggies, and get plenty of exercise? Of course not, that would be as reasonable as saying that dumping out water bottles and taking off shoes isn't making us any safer.