12 ms·
The problem is not the rationality assumption per se. It is that the set of inputs and constraints to the decision process considered in classical economics is
by jandrewrogers 13y ago
The problem is not the rationality assumption per se. It is that the set of inputs and constraints to the decision process considered in classical economics is sufficiently narrow and incomplete that it does not produce a realistic output. Actors generally appear "irrational" primarily because classical economics simplifies the modeling process by discarding relevant context that influences decision processes for the sake of simple analysis.
Also, "rational" is contextual, not objective or axiomatic in any real-world finite computational system as a matter of mathematics. This is an important distinction often ignored. As a consequence, "irrationality" can be generally defined as "making a decision from a different contextual basis". Again, this defeats the desire to create absolute rules of economics that fit in a soundbite.
Economics is perfectly capable of dealing with the complexities of real-world actors in theory. In practice, most economists attempt to reduce the complex dynamics implied by the theory into trivial theorems that are easy to turn into government policy. This is somewhat understandable because even approximating a pure model is computationally prohibitive. This provides a lovely framework within which any economist can come up with a narrow model that suits their particular ideological proclivities. You rarely see an economist that properly recognizes the constraints and assumptions of their model but those limitations exist nonetheless. Advanced computer science will allow us to implement the more general models directly regardless of whether or not the results are politically convenient, but it may take a while before we see it.