3 ms·
Pitman is right: people are contradictory. In the Naggum thread the other day I criticized him for polarizing and ultimately damaging the Lisp community. What
by gruseom 17y ago
Pitman is right: people are contradictory.
In the Naggum thread the other day I criticized him for polarizing and ultimately damaging the Lisp community. What I didn't say is that I almost always enjoyed reading him, even at his most noxious. He was a master not only of Common Lisp but of English, the latter to a degree surprising in a non-native speaker (Norwegians routinely excel at it but he was over the top). And through reading him I became fond of him, something that by no means always happens. I'm not surprised to hear people say that he was a nice person. People are contradictory.
- kragen 17y agoI agree that people are contradictory and that Naggum was a master of CL and English.
- gruseom 17y agoI've been reading various things about Naggum that have appeared in the last few days. It's changed my view of him. For example, I wouldn't write "consummate intellectual bully" to describe him anymore. He was more subtle than that (though his language was not) and had a kind of integrity that bullies don't. I hadn't read enough of him to grok this, but recent posts by his intelligent admirers caused me to take a deeper look. Truly a fascinating character. Online communication is a limited medium that is prone to feedback loops of escalating misunderstanding. It's easy to slip into thinking that one is talking to a computer rather than another human being because, in a way, one is. At that point, why bother with anything other than the intellectual satisfaction of formulating what you have to say in the sharpest, most absolute way possible? Many of us are prone to this. Naggum took it to an extreme. I still think there's something to criticize here, but perhaps not in terms like nasty, cruel, etc. It has more to do with dissociation (as when the cognitive apparatus becomes disconnected from emotional or other information). Which is another something many of us are prone to. One other point about Erik Naggum that deserves a little more attention than it's gotten: during much of the time he was writing this stuff he was suffering physically pretty badly. That's not an excuse, but it does change my picture of what was going on there.