2 ms·
In my opinion, yours is so far the best comment on this thread. You analyzed the model, made your own, and cut to the heard of the matter. That's probably becau
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
In my opinion, yours is so far the best comment on this thread. You analyzed the model, made your own, and cut to the heard of the matter. That's probably because you actually wrote some code and played with the model.
Thank you. I look forward to seeing your alternative model. Please email me if this thread vanishes before you write it up, I really want to see it.
- scarmig 13y agoThanks--I appreciate you starting this discussion with this approach, and I almost feel guilty about pushing BI incessantly without doing this as due diligence before. Most people don't seem to get that models are useful starting places and tools for understanding, not the answer itself. Even when you state that explicitly...
- notahacker 13y agoA corollary of your observation is that the BI is proposed to replace retirement benefits, whereas the BJ as specified in the model provides income for employed people and registered disabled only. Since BJ advocates seldom oppose the principle of state-aid for the retired, you'd probably need to start by solving this (pretty easily by adding "retired_person" and "administrative_cost_per_retired_person" variables) which would substantially reduce the cost gap between the two proposals.