3 ms·
I think we'd all be better off and get to a user-centric mobile experience a lot sooner by isolating the network communication in a dedicated device. I'm toyin
by mindslight 13y ago
I think we'd all be better off and get to a user-centric mobile experience a lot sooner by isolating the network communication in a dedicated device.
I'm toying with the idea that next time I have to upgrade my mobile (hopefully not soon), a better way to go is something like mifi + netbook + smart watch (+ maybe some compact chorded keyboard).
- rsync 13y agoExactly. If you want a mobile phone that you control, you need to buy something like a samsung galaxy player (contains no baseband processor, contains no mobile phone infrastructure) and then attach a USB modem to it (or carry a MIFI or whatever). There's one problem, however, and that is all of the fancy noise cancellation and voice smoothing are actually done on the baseband proc, and userland implementations of this for VOIP apps are typically pretty crummy. Me, I am sticking with my MOTO FONE / F3 for now.
- alexwright 13y agoI'd be (pleasantly) surprised if devices like the Galaxy Player didn't still have binary blobs for the Wifi/BT and video hardware. Even NICs for otherwise fairly open PC/ATX machines all still have the proprietary blob firmware drivers.
- tmzt 13y agoThe Mifi is the same thing as the baseband in your cell phone, and can even do SMS. Many of them are running Linux on the AP side now to support more advanced Wifi routing features. If you were really paranoid, you might consider the possibility that it has a microphone or a speaker that can be treated like a microphone. (Though I don't know of any that actually have a beeping, vibrator or piezo output.) Also, they may have some form of e911-compliant GPS receiver, though whether the RF is hooked up for it I wouldn't know.
- mindslight 13y agoWell even a completely trustable cell radio is tracked with tower triangulation. The only way I see to fix this is to completely rearchitect the mobile network by getting rid of subscriber IDs, using anonymous payments for tower access, and then a mix network for transit privacy. That is to say, location data is a wash for the foreseeable future.. Surreptitious microphones and other sensors are indeed still a problem, but they seem easy to audit/remove in the short term, and if this model catches on and they become a real threat, the physical audits just have to go deeper. What you do gain is a processor that can be trusted by the user (in the same way we all trust Intel CPUs), with the Mifi only seeing encrypted communications. Also we've moved the demarc point solidly between two separate physical devices - upgrade your pocket computer without involving your cell provider, and replace your communications ability without affecting your user environment.
- tmzt 13y agoWell first you're assuming that those that created the system consider known identity to be a misfeature, even beyond that necessary for payments. Trustable/trusted doesn't mean trustworthy in the sense of an individual citizen's expectation of privacy, it means that you have given the entity your private information, in trade for service and convenience. The irony of old spy tradecraft is that we all possess hardware that could conceal in plain sight anything that previously had to be hidden completely, the existence of electronics or recording/transmitting ability (including film) would immediately indicate the role of the person as someone engaged in some kind of espionage. Now we can all carry sophisticated sensors and communication devices in most places, and all but cameras in many others. What physical audit would tell you if the MEMS sensor in your device has been repurposed for audio pickup. (Assuming that the capability isn't already in the firmware, or that simple observation of the signal output (including power fluctuations) could reveal the same information to the microprocessor. The only case I'm aware of where the courts have blocked this kind of surveillance involved an OnStar vehicle system using an analog cellphone which could only serve it's intended purpose or the government's, but not both simultaneously. This is not an issue with digital and IP-based systems, which can easily serve two masters. Ah, you're use of "trust" again, Intel CPUs have features that actively work against you, such as with vPRO. I would agree that a non-cellular PDA and Mifi are superior to an integrated device from a privacy and personal autonomy perspective.