4 ms·
Do you really want to tax ability?
- iron_ball 17y agoDisingenuous at best. Tax incentives around mortages, charitable contributions, and child health insurance are social signals: legislation saying 'this is what we value as a society, these are the things we want to help you with.' If you disagree with that kind of legislation, argue against it directly. This business about height determining earning potential is utterly irrelevant to your real complaints. And the math is foolish to begin with: if height determines income level, and you really want to try to equalize for that factor, you should be applying credits/penalties to bring people of different height to the same level -- not taking people who are already at the same level and elevating the short one above the tall one. After all, if they make the same income despite their height difference, it stands to reason that the shorter person is more productive. Applying a credit/penalty when incomes are already equal is the wrong way to argue the (already misguided) point.
- pmorici 17y agoThe difference between height and those other things the government determines taxes on is that height is not a choice, it's an innate characteristic of a person. People find taxing on height repulsive because it is more or less equivalent to taxing on race which everyone would immediately see as wrong and would be prohibited by the constitution. In order for this guys argument to hold water he should have used a case other than height which involved a component of personal choice and invoked the same feeling of injustice in people.
- huangm 17y agoCan you please provide an argument for why choice ought to be the principal factor for some attribute to be taxable? The justification is in no way clear to me.
- iron_ball 17y agoWould you agree that taxes should be just? If so, would you agree that it is unjust to tax someone for something he has no choice in?
- anamax 17y ago> If so, would you agree that it is unjust to tax someone for something he has no choice in? Hmm. No one chooses their parents. Should rich kids be taxed like poor kids? > Would you agree that taxes should be just? I'll agree that "just" has no agreed-on definition and is used as a way to imply that the other person is bad. As such, I find it a useful signalling device in a discussion.
- iron_ball 17y agoNobody wins arguments on the internet, so let's agree to be unable to agree on the definitions of terms about which to disagree.
- anamax 17y agoPeople win arguments on the web all the time. What's rare (and different) is at argument that persuades some of the participants. Are you certain that you don't want to argue that "just", the word on which your argument and position depends, actually has a useful and good meaning?
- pmorici 17y agoI don't have a justification I'm just observing that choice vs. an inherit attribute is generally the stratifying line used in our society to determine wether or not it is just to apply a man made penalty or advantage to a particular state. Because of that I think that the comparison of using height as a deciding factor in taxation is like comparing apples and oranges.
- amalcon 17y agoOr maybe 4: That the conclusion is misguided. The effect of height on income is already taxed... by income taxes. This proposal would entail double-taxing this effect. Surely we don't want an additional tax on (say) doctors simply because doctors are likely to earn more. The regular income tax handles that effect.
- vomjom 17y agoWow, you completely missed the point. Obviously, the author knows that height is already taxed. The real point is that some members of society are more productive than others. Apparently, tall people are more productive than short people. What we want to make equal (from a utilitarian point of view) is income per unit effort. If you're from a disadvantaged background, but put as much effort as a person from an advantaged background, then you would make the same after-tax income. He's demonstrating that this point of view is impractical in reality.
- amalcon 17y agoHe doesn't need to demonstrate the impracticality in that. Everyone already knows that measuring effort is impossible in practice. edit: His final claim -- that the tax on height is an explicit consequence of a utilitarian approach -- is simply flawed (or irrelevant, actually) because we do have a tax on height. A progressive income tax is meant to approximate what would happen if we accounted for all of these variables, but without actually accounting for each one explicitly, as that would be impractical. Now, I'm not saying that the utilitarian method is the end-all. If it is flawed (which I think it is), this is simply not the flaw.
- jjs 17y ago> Apparently, tall people are more productive than short people. Or, having (fallible!) humans doing the hiring has created certain inefficiencies in the labor market; inefficiencies which could be exploited/corrected by someone clever.
- msluyter 17y agoIf you're from a disadvantaged background, but put as much effort as a person from an advantaged background, then you would make the same after-tax income. I think this misrepresents the notion behind progressive taxation. I'm no expert, but I understand it like this: because of declining marginal utility, the same % of income may mean much more to the poor than to the rich. If my yearly income is 10k, then 10% of it might mean the difference between making rent or not. If I make 100k, 10% of it may mean forgoing some luxury, but needn't substantively impact my overall quality of life. In that sense, the subjective impact of money is not fixed by its objective value; it's more important to those that have less of it. This is borne out by research. Money significantly impacts happiness until you make enough to basically get into the (lower) middle class, and then it has little impact. So, if you buy the above intuition and want to use taxation to help maximize happiness (utilitarianism), then you would want some form of progressive taxation in order to alleviate the negative impact of poverty. This doesn't mean "making everyone equal." To test our intuitions about this subject, I like philosopher John Rawls' conception of a "Veil of Ignorance." Rawls would ask: would you rather live in a society with, say, 1% billionaires and everyone else in poverty, or one more evenly distributed around a middle class -- without knowing in advance where you would end up in this society? The answer may well depend on one's level of risk tolerance, but I'd wager that most people wold opt for the latter.
- gojomo 17y agoA similar analysis might be applied along the dimension of age, following the recent observations, in several places, that despite (for example) Warren Buffett's riches, few 20-year-olds would want to switch places with him. 60 years of life is worth more than $60 billion dollars, to most people, so every 20-year-old is in some sense "richer" than Buffett. So should strict egalitarians tax the young more than the old? (Don't worry, it'll even out over a lifetime!)
- astrodust 17y agoThis is a pretty weak argument to be making. There's no specific reason to provide for a transfer of wealth from tall people to short people, it doesn't provide any specific social benefit. At best this is some kind of amateurish Libertarian raving, or a thinly veiled troll.
- duncanj 17y agoAnd this troll wrote a popular economics textbook.
- davidw 17y agoMankiw's a smart guy, but he's also very much a Republican: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N._Gregory_Mankiw http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/N._Gregory_Mankiw He served under Bush, and as an advisor to Romney. I'm not saying there's something wrong with Republicans, just that at times he tends to be a bit of a "party man". Lately, his writing has taken a turn that's more along the lines of "sniping at Obama and company", rather than writing anything particularly interesting... sort of like Krugman with Bush. Anyway, all very much off topic...
- iron_ball 17y agoThat fact in itself confers no legitimacy. In fact, given what I've read about the textbook industry, it does not even imply that his work has been improved by any authorities worthy of respect.
- anamax 17y ago> There's no specific reason to provide for a transfer of wealth from tall people to short people, it doesn't provide any specific social benefit. Sure it does. It helps people who are disadvantaged. It's like giving preferences to middle class black people over lower-class white people.
- ewanmcteagle 17y agoIt's meant to be a criticism of the utilitarian view of taxation. Read this: http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/06/defending-mankiw.html http://www.overcomingbias.com/2009/06/defending-mankiw.html It's not logically inconsistent