35 ms·
I'd always heard that children's chemistry sets got increasingly dumbed down because of a combination of direct regulation of common chemicals, under the rubric
by bradleyjg 13y ago
I'd always heard that children's chemistry sets got increasingly dumbed down because of a combination of direct regulation of common chemicals, under the rubric of both the War on Drugs and the War on Terror, and fear of tort liability.
Is that not the case?
- girvo 13y agoWell it certainly does make some useful chemicals annoying to get.
- fr0sty 13y ago> Is that not the case? It is the case, and is the reason this set is put together. Here's a BBC article on the subject: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-19050342 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-19050342
- cjfont 13y agoSo wouldn't all of those reasons also apply to this chemistry set as well? What is it about this one that would mitigate the same concerns as applied to other sets?
- solarmist 13y agoThat's the whole point of this set it to allow you to do the "dangerous" (read: interesting) experiments. None of it is illegal, but it just discards the last 50 years of increasing concern for allowing children to do dangerous things. So yes it's a risk and it can be used to make illegal/dangerous substances, but none of it is illegal, just risky. Just major companies don't want to take on the kind of risk that comes with it. Whereas boutique shops have a lot more freedom because they're selling to self selecting audiences, which (generally) understand they're taking on additional risks with the increased benefits.
- mildtrepidation 13y agoWhereas boutique shops have a lot more freedom because they're selling to self selecting audiences, which (generally) understand they're taking on additional risks with the increased benefits. They may take advantage of having the same freedoms that larger companies just don't exercise, but the idea that their audience is "self-selecting" likely won't hold up or protect them from the kind of litigation that means this is (in practice) a bad idea (from a business survival standpoint). I see the set as a good thing, but I don't think saying they're protected in any way or that the concerns of larger companies don't apply is accurate.
- solarmist 13y agoThat's exactly my point. Won't help them in the slightest, but they're willing to do it anyway and I applaud them for it.
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoThey aren't as attractive a target for lawsuits because of their size.
- CamperBob2 13y agoThe guy with the Kickstarter runs a science supply shop/museum called the "H. M. S. Beagle," in Kansas City. He's already no stranger to risk. I need to do some more research to make sure I'm not supporting some sort of kook, but I like what I've read about him (and from him) so far. If he checks out at face value I'll participate in his Kickstarter at a higher-than-strictly-necessary level, just to support what he's doing.
- noluckatall 13y agoI've met the guy; he's legit. My wife and I stop by every time we visit KC because it's such a neat shop. I've looked for a store like his in the NYC area without success.
- SamuelMulder 13y ago
- fnordfnordfnord 13y agoI don't think it was ever made illegal to have or sell these things, just very inconvenient to sell them.
- Pxtl 13y agoThe image shows sulfuric acid right up front. I can't imagine why they no longer sell those to kids. However, if you think about it then as long as you provide the proper MSDS data-sheets and get the right waivers signed, providing a one-stop-shop chemistry set for educators/parents makes perfect sense.
- SmurfsRUs 13y agoDoes the kit contain Methylamine? Red Phosphorus? Ergot alkaloids by chance?
- ballard 13y agoPDF pp 2-3: http://www.hms-beagle.com/PDFs/BenchMark_Legacy_Chemicals_Plus_Kit.pdf http://www.hms-beagle.com/PDFs/BenchMark_Legacy_Chemicals_Pl... Any bio&|chem know what's likely to do singe eyebrows or suffocate?
- csmuk 13y agoWell potassium nitrate is a pretty strong oxidiser. Mill it with a pestle+mortar and mix it with icing sugar 1:1 by mass. Put 30-40g on some alu foil. Setting fire to that will produce crap loads of smoke very quickly. I filled my entire garden up with smoke with one of them a couple of years ago. Sure there are more in that list but that strikes me as the most obvious.
- Florin_Andrei 13y agoI was a chemistry nutcase in high school, and even I would draw the line at ergot.
- PaulMcCartney 13y agoI don't get the chemistry of it, but the kit says it will also include ricin as some kind of safety measure.
- FishmanJack 13y agoI love rhetorical questions! No, no and no.
- jonlucc 13y agoI went to college not far from that shop and I shared a class with a former local police officer. We were discussing meth production (I can't remember how the topic casually came up in a Spanish class) and he said the cops almost always have people stationed outside the store. They are quite aware the place sells all of the needed equipment and some of the materials necessary for making meth.
- FishmanJack 13y agoI doubt the veracity of your classmates statement. Besides, laboratory equipment of all sizes and shapes are now sold through national hardware chains.
- CamperBob2 13y agoUnfortunately he's probably spot-on. In Texas, the glassware itself is illegal to own without registering it with the state Department of Public Safety.
- frozenport 13y agoMarket shrunk, consider all the fun things kids could be doing instead of chemistry? In the 1950s there were no video games or computers. Now we live in the future.