5 ms·
Oh come on that does not even make sense. >>> More people living doesn't necessarily mean people living better lives. In a finite world with limits to
by lifeisstillgood 13y ago
Oh come on that does not even make sense.
>>> More people living doesn't necessarily mean people
living better lives. In a finite world with limits to
growth, relaxing one bottleneck only leads to the next
bottleneck.
Its not that people think gosh I have 1000 more calories, I will have another child, its that without those 1000 calories either the mother dies before or during pregnancy or the child dies after, of starvation.
Granted there are now lots of other things to kill the child, malaria etc, but I guarantee every single person on HN will rather take the chance of malaria than the certainty of not being born in the first place.
I also guarantee that most of HN places themselves on the "not yet happy" side of the fence, so I find your argument which seems to be "its no good bringing another child into this world, they might not die of starvation but something will get them, and they will never be happy" to fly in the face of, well, millions of years of evolution. We've always been unhappy.
More people is a good thing, more people, and in a world that knows it should use its wealth to provide decent sanitation, opportunities, education, peace and justice, it is an unalloyed good.
- arca_vorago 13y agoI don't think you understood his comment fully. He was not claiming that "people think gosh I have 1000 more calories, I will have another child" it's that with increasing lifespans globally, the population is booming, but the "world that knows it should use its wealth to provide decent sanitation, opportunities, education, peace and justice" doesn't exist anywhere but your head. So the world pop is now 7 billion + but the things needed to keep that population in a good condition are not manifesting. Essentially we are setting ourselves up for things like massive famines, biological diseases, etc. It has nothing to do with happiness, and more people means more people suffering.
- tptacek 13y agoThat's what Erlich said, while people like Borlaug successfully worked the problem.
- mistermann 13y ago> but the "world that knows it should use its wealth to provide decent sanitation, opportunities, education, peace and justice" doesn't exist anywhere but your head. Incorrect, that idea exists in the heads of many people, and many of them are doing something about it. > the things needed to keep that population in a good condition are not manifesting. Incorrect. Standard of living is improving for most people. > Essentially we are setting ourselves up for things like massive famines, biological diseases, etc. I'm open minded and willing to be convinced, but it will take more than a mere opinion. I don't see anything compelling in the news that even suggests this is likely. > It has nothing to do with happiness, and more people means more people suffering. So we shall just ignore happiness, but focus on suffering? Got it.
- arca_vorago 13y agoHere are some good papers, there are lots more, but a small primer on what I am talking about. Bottom line is this, I was replying to the response to this comment "More people living doesn't necessarily mean people living better lives. In a finite world with limits to growth, relaxing one bottleneck only leads to the next bottleneck." that said "this doesn't even make sense" I'm showing that it does make some sense, though there is plenty of room for debate. I think too many people misinterpreted his comment for Malthusianism. Here are a few papers on the matter: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1846696/pdf/brmedj02604-0062.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1846696/pdf/brme... http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3586590/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3586590/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1811054/pdf/procrsmed00289-0015.pdf http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1811054/pdf/proc... http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1332674/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1332674/
- hackinthebochs 13y ago> but I guarantee every single person on HN will rather take the chance of malaria than the certainty of not being born in the first place. Perhaps that's true. But what about kids in all the destitute places on the planet? Using an average HN user as your test case just shows how biased your perspective is. Personally I'd rather not be born than be born in a place where I have a high change of dying of malaria, or dysentery.
- tptacek 13y agoExactly how is it relevant that you would rather not be born than be born in rural poverty? Congratulations. Nobody asked you, or anybody else. Now what?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- selmnoo 13y ago> Nobody asked you, or anybody else. Huh? And nobody asked you to reply to his comment. My goodness tptacek, this is a discussion board. Open-ended conversations take place here that drift off to all places. Sometimes they lead to interesting points, sometimes they don't. I see no reason to mock someone for that.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoif Tptacek had said "nobody asked you " I would agree. But he said nobody asked you or anyone else. None of us chose to be born, nor born into the circumstances we find ourselves. As we cannot control if we win or lose the lottery of western luxury or extreme poverty, those on the winning side should say "let's fix this" not "well if I was that unlucky I would rather be dead, so why can't they all just die and leave me alone" which is rather the undercurrent I was reading.
- hackinthebochs 13y agoPerhaps if you dusted off the old reading comprehension you would realize I was responding specifically to the claim that nobody on HN would X. I am someone on HN therefore my counter-point was very relevant.
- genwin 13y ago> More people is a good thing A sustainable population is better. There are many indications that the current world population is unsustainable. With the oceans being quickly depleted of fish, for one small example, I doubt that even 2 billion people can survive in the long run. Everyone eating Solyent is not a solution in my book.
- collyw 13y ago"but I guarantee every single person on HN will rather take the chance of malaria than the certainty of not being born in the first place." You would have to assume that anyone who didn't want to be here would have topped themselves already.
- Houshalter 13y ago>Granted there are now lots of other things to kill the child, malaria etc, but I guarantee every single person on HN will rather take the chance of malaria than the certainty of not being born in the first place. Actually no. More people isn't automatically good. Taken to it's extreme this would mean just making as many people as is physically possible with the lowest standard of living possible. There has to be some trade off between number of people vs happiness per person. Then there is the many worlds thing argument http://lesswrong.com/lw/ws/for_the_people_who_are_still_alive/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/ws/for_the_people_who_are_still_aliv...