3 ms·
Perhaps you should have read it, because the proposal has nothing to do with communism. Under communism the means production are owned by the state - consequen
by onion2k 13y ago
Perhaps you should have read it, because the proposal has nothing to do with communism.
Under communism the means production are owned by the state - consequently everyone is an employee of the government, and from that springs equality. Only it doesn't, obviously, because the people organising it all tend to keep more for themselves. People are greedy when they have the opportunity.
The system the article is outlining is essentially the notion that if you give everyone a small amount of money, enough to live without being in poverty but not a fortune, then the societal benefits from lower crime, lower healthcare bills, improved quality of life all round, and so forth, makes everyone better off. There'd still be plenty of incentive to work because you wouldn't be able to afford the luxuries we enjoy if you didn't, but on the other hand people would have the option to work less and, for example, care for their relatives rather than having to work more as they do now. Ultimately society wins.
It's a very interesting proposal. Especially if you're a liberal (small l).
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoCommunism is a classless, moneyless society in which the means of production are not owned at all, but held totally in common and allocated based on usage for labor. Socialism is when workers control the means of production. State socialism is a specialized form of socialism in which the state acts as the arm of workers.
- sologoub 13y ago"allocated based on usage for labor." You mean based on need? Don't recall there being any kind of qualifier that you have to work X amount to get Y, which would essentially be barter capitalism (without currency that is). Under theoretical communism, the allocation is equal to all individuals and has no preferential treatment. Of course, that's not really achievable in the current form of the human condition, as the history amply shows.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoUsage for labor just means, "You get the means of production by using them", or, "Everyone directly controls what they use, and nothing else."
- bmj 13y agoSocialism is when workers control the means of production. I might be picking nits, but Socialism is when a group controls the means of production. This can be workers, or the state, or simply a group of citizens. Think of a cooperative: I own a share in the coop, but do not work there. I can help drive the direction of the organization. There is no requirement that a member-owner must be a worker.
- binxbolling 13y agoJust to clarify: my understanding was that, in very broad strokes, it's socialism in which the means of production are owned by the state. Then in communism the means of production are owned by the community, in syndicalism they're owned by the workers, and in capitalism they're owned by individuals (or legal individuals). For example, take ACME Inc, located in Anytown, USA: - in socialism, ACME is owned by the US government - in communism, ACME is owned by Anytown - in syndicalism, ACME is owned by ACME employees - in capitalism, ACME is owned by an individual, or collection of individuals, that may have little-or-nothing to do with ACME itself. Open to correction and I'll re-iterate that these are enormous generalizations.
- erikpukinskis 13y agoI'm partial to a form of syndicalism where ACME is owned by everyone who has an interest in it, and the syndicate is simply a consensing subset of those people. Other syndicates may form and will have equal "ownership" of the ACME "assets". Usage rights are negotiated then through social norms around divisibility (we cut the cake until it'd be pointless to cut it further). Essentially, there is no property. I'm not sure if there is a term for this. I always thought that was what anarcho-syndicalism was, but reading on Wikipedia says that term indicates this "worker-owned" setup that you're describing.