2 ms·
> Password hints are an absolutely ridiculous security measure. Password hints have multiple uses. For identity management and verification systems, it's used
by peterwwillis 13y ago
> Password hints are an absolutely ridiculous security measure.
Password hints have multiple uses. For identity management and verification systems, it's used as an additional identity check after the password if the host seems to have changed. For password recovery, it's a "need to know" factor you have to pass before you get to the "need to have" of e-mail account access. Since it's trivial to bruteforce, multiple hints of different categories are usually deployed.
In the real world, hackers compromise accounts by finding out the personal details they need to subvert password-recovery steps. Find the last four of the social, their birth date, address, and phone number, and you can basically hijack any bank, telephone, utility or government account a person has. Password hints are (when properly implemented) more secure because they can leverage other access methods.
Did they need to keep the hint plaintext? No; they can hash it just like any other password. But as the complexity requirement of the hint is much lower than that of passwords, it should be required to use another factor (such as an e-mailed confirmation code, SMS, or many more hints or sensitive information) to allow the hint to succeed.
- mikeash 13y agoI think you've mixed up password hints with security questions. You seem to be talking about stuff of the form, "What is my mother's maiden name?" A password hint is exactly what it says: a hint for what your password was, to help you avoid forgetting it. If your password is "lassie", then your password hint might be something like, "That dog you like from TV." The problem, of course, is that just about any hint that helps you remember your password also helps an attacker guess it.
- peterwwillis 13y agoAh, you're right, got the two confused