3 ms·
At least in the US (which has the largest software industry of anywhere in the world), the title of engineer is not regulated. Only the title "Professional Engi
by TheCoelacanth 13y ago
At least in the US (which has the largest software industry of anywhere in the world), the title of engineer is not regulated. Only the title "Professional Engineer" is regulated. Accreditation for engineers only applies to areas that have an impact on public safety. This means that civil engineers usually are accredited, but mechanical and electrical engineers usually aren't. So for people located in the US, it is perfectly appropriate to refer to someone as a software engineer.
- kabouseng 13y agoPlease don't find this reply condescending :D But Americans also call their train operators "engineers"...
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoI don't find that condescending. What I do find condescending is attempting to apply the laws of certain countries to the world as a whole. There are, in fact, many jurisdictions where being an engineer does not require any form of accreditation. The fact that some jurisdictions do require accreditation does not give engineers in other jurisdictions any less claim to the title.
- kabouseng 13y agoWhere did I do that? You were the one highlighting America as having the biggest software industry...
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoThe part where you claimed that only people who are officially accredited are engineers. People who live and work somewhere without such accreditation are completely justified in calling themselves engineers without being accredited.
- kabouseng 13y agoMy apologies then, I was not trying to force my viewpoint, I only shared it. Just as I don't believe anyone who's read Gray's anatomy (the book) can or should call themselves a doctor, just the same I don't believe anyone writing code should call themselves an engineer...
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoSo, according to your viewpoint, there were no doctor's in the US until the late 1800's?
- kabouseng 13y agoYou'll have to provide a bit more context for me. But again comparing modern day professions to the 19th century equivalent does not bode well for your argument. If you'd prefer the medical industry return to its standards and practices of the 19th century, your welcome to visit such a doctor. I prefer my modern day certified medical professional.
- TheCoelacanth 13y agoThe late 1800's is when doctors were first licensed in the US. Before that doctors practiced medicine but were not licensed, yet they were still doctors. Official licensing undoubtedly raises the quality of doctor's practicing medicine, but it is not an inherent quality of being a doctor. In most places, someone is not allowed to practice medicine without a license, but in places without medical licensing, someone who practices medicine without a license is still a doctor. Engineering is the same. Licensing most likely raises the quality of engineers, but that does not mean an unlicensed person who does the job of an engineer is not an engineer.
- kabouseng 13y agoPray do tell where in the world is an unlicensed medical practitioner called a docter? My point being, in this day and age, to call yourself a docter, you must be licensed. Bringing up history does nothing to change that fact. I would state that should also apply for engineers, and already does in most countries. Merely the fact that train drivers are called engineers in the US proves my point. It dilutes the term to be basically meaningless.