4 ms·
> Legalize and regulate prostitution, boom you've eliminated the market for sex slavery Not all sex slaves are legal age adults who would compete against a leg
by bane 13y ago
> Legalize and regulate prostitution, boom you've eliminated the market for sex slavery
Not all sex slaves are legal age adults who would compete against a legal prostitution environment.
- msandford 13y agoYeah that's true. But if you legalize prostitution the majority of the people with fairly normal tastes in sex would find willing "vendors." That would free police up from fighting "normal" prostitution and enable them to put more energy into finding and stopping the really naughty stuff like child slavery and the like which are real, but niche problems.
- jlgreco 13y agoDrug dealers are typically willing to sell their wares to children. This makes sense, since what they are doing is illegal anyway. If we legalize a drug (say, alcohol), then the people who sell that particular drug will typically no longer be willing to sell that drug to minors, since minors represent a very small percentage of the market and (with the legalization of the larger segment of the market) carry a much greater risk that cannot be justified by the marginal profit gains they could see. This is why it is easier for a teenager to buy marijuana than alcohol in significant quantities.
- DanBC 13y ago> If we legalize a drug (say, alcohol), then the people who sell that particular drug will typically no longer be willing to sell that drug to minors, The years of campaigning and changing laws to prevent shops (and pubs) from selling alcohol and cigarettes to children show that actually they don't give a fuck who they sell to so long as they sell. Marketing tobacco products with youth friendly cartoon camels or with names like Skol Bandits is sleazy. Big tobacco had no problem targeting children even though they knew it was illegal. {As always in these discussions: I am strongly in favour of legalising all drugs}
- jlgreco 13y agoThe laws need to be enforced to work, I would never suggest otherwise. The fact is when the laws are enforced it becomes difficult for teenagers to buy liquor themselves and, absent people who make a living selling liquor illegally (these people still exist in some remote parts of Alaska, and in some very poor areas of the rural Appalachians, but not really elsewhere), teenagers will have a difficult time finding a reliable source of alcohol (Joe's older brother who goes to college may pick you up a keg once in a while for your parties, but Joe's older brother has better things to do than buy teenagers booze all the time, even if he's gouging them) On the other hand, reliable sources of pot is easy for a teenager. The people who are willing to illegally sell pot to teenagers are already selling to a larger more affluent audience illegally as well (adults). Basically: Selling alcohol to everybody illegally: Laws are enforced: profitable, and risky. Laws are not enforced: profitable. Selling alcohol to only adults legally: profitable. Selling alcohol to only minors illegally: Laws are enforced: not profitable, and risky. Laws are not enforced: not profitable. Selling alcohol to adults legally and minors illegally: Laws are enforced: profitable, but needlessly risky for what you gain. Laws are not enforced: profitable. Given that you want to restrict childrens' access to substances, you want to be in a position where no adult considers it worth it to sell to children. The best place for that is "selling to adults is legal, selling to children is illegal, the law is enforced".
- alandarev 13y agoHow is selling a same product, to already willing to buy customer, is not profittable? Increasing the sales by several percent without any extra expenses is certainly profitable. To sell alcohol to kids, they do not need to invent new 'kid friendly bottles' and dump millions into 'kid oriented marketing', they are already here to buy, just sell the damn same product and here is the profit.
- xixi77 13y agoHowever, for some reason we don't see hordes of underage slaves manning McDonald's, do we? Perhaps it has something to do with the fact that burger joints are legal, and hence violating labor laws has real consequences for their proprietors, and sex work isn't, so labor laws have no relevance?
- bane 13y agoYes you do, and illegal immigrant workers and illegal immigrant underage workers. [1][2][3][4] Legalizing prostitution was floated as an instant fix for the human trafficking problem, when it...by very simple example...isn't. 1 - http://articles.baltimoresun.com/2010-07-13/news/bs-md-co-mcdonalds-labor-20100713_1_labor-laws-child-labor-40-hour-week http://articles.baltimoresun.com/2010-07-13/news/bs-md-co-mc... 2 - http://denver.cbslocal.com/2012/12/04/denver-mcdonalds-franchise-owner-cited-for-child-labor-violations/ http://denver.cbslocal.com/2012/12/04/denver-mcdonalds-franc... 3 - http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2001/aug/01/childprotection.society http://www.theguardian.com/uk/2001/aug/01/childprotection.so... 4 - http://www.examiner.com/article/illegal-aliens-caught-working-mcdonald-s-restaurants-again-w-video http://www.examiner.com/article/illegal-aliens-caught-workin...
- quinnchr 13y agoAm I missing something? Everyone of those links is about someone being caught and punished for breaking labor laws. Yes it still happens, but when it happens there's a mechanism to punish the perpetrators and help the victims (In most of the articles you linked the employee's received their back wages). Why should sex workers not enjoy the same protection?
- bane 13y agoSo two questions: 1) Do you think that the few times McD's was caught with underage or otherwise illegal workers represents all the times that underage and or otherwise illegal workers are used (that enforcement of the law is 100% effective)? My obvious assertion is that it probably wouldn't be reported in the news if it wasn't caught and that enforcement of labor laws is less than 100% effective. 2) Do you think we should have a legal framework that allows for underage sex workers? Because we already have one that doesn't allow for such an occupation by minors yet it's still a shockingly common part of human sex slave trafficking. It also caters to a type of client who wouldn't necessarily be affected by a prostitution legalization regime.