3 ms·
> ... naturalist fallacy: you believe ... distinction ...that doesn't exist. I believe no such thing. I don't know what you read, but in the body glutamic aci
by ars 13y ago
> ... naturalist fallacy: you believe ... distinction ...that doesn't exist.
I believe no such thing.
I don't know what you read, but in the body glutamic acid doesn't just float around randomly, it's carefully stored near the nerves that need it. Excess glutamic acid where it doesn't belong causes nerve problems.
It's like the difference between sucrose and starch. Chemically they are the same, but the effects are very different because one needs more digestion than the other.
- tptacek 13y agoYour body can't metabolize nitrogen without glutamic acid. It's part of how you, and I think maybe all the rest of your siblings in phylum chordata, build proteins. I don't see a lot of reason to believe that it causes "nerve problems" in the human body, but would welcome a citation to the literature that shows that. It gets worse for your argument. Here's a paper that demonstrates that very large oral doses of MSG in both mice and humans don't even significantly raise the plasma concentration of glutamates. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3136011/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3136011/ This should probably be unsurprising. Your body is designed to deal with consumption of glutamates; in fact, even though it's so vital to your system that you produce it yourself, humans get most of their glutamic acid from dietary sources. Hypersensitivity to dietary glutamate would be maladaptive. The idea that your body has carefully delineated locations where it's safe to have glutamic acid (probably not coincidentally in the nervous system, the most complex part of the body), and that ingesting "artificial" sources of glutamic acid throws that out of whack, is again I think a manifestation of the naturalistic fallacy.