2 ms·
While the OP is another article in the long line of articles themed: "Big government planning has unintended consequences"...what stuck out to me in the OP was
by danso 13y ago
While the OP is another article in the long line of articles themed: "Big government planning has unintended consequences"...what stuck out to me in the OP was that the intent of this plan was actually quite good and sensible, in terms of forward thinking as China grows:
> The idea was to consolidate the villages into one new town called Huaming that would take up less than one square mile, versus the three square miles that the dozen villages had occupied. A portion of the remaining 59 square miles could be sold to developers to pay for construction costs, meaning the new buildings would cost farmers and the government nothing.
* The rest of the land would stay agricultural, but worked by a few remaining farmers using modern methods. This would achieve another aim: not reducing the amount of arable land — a crucial goal for a country with a huge population and historic worries about being able to feed itself.*
Consolidate the population into a city -- with lots of green space and modern apartments -- so that the land could be more efficiently farmed? Sounds like a great intention...but it's not the intention that's bad, it's the [insert your favorite reference to government bureaucracy/tendency for institutions to harm the individual].
What makes this article more depressing than most is its reaffirmation that more technology/modernization almost never benefits the people closest to it. For a very long time, farming has been unquestionably improved by technology and planning...but has that resulted in farmers living decent human lives as machines take over their work? Not always. So I think it's quite optimistic to think that as other classes of citizens find their work automated and modernized, they too will not reap the promised benefits, even if society, in the long run, benefits.