3 ms·
I support the Wikipedia anti-battleground policy. It creates a better community and reduces flame wars. Think of an HN where every comment where written for a p
by belorn 13y ago
I support the Wikipedia anti-battleground policy. It creates a better community and reduces flame wars. Think of an HN where every comment where written for a productive and positive discussion, and one would describe a welcoming and friendly community. This is the goal of the Wikipedia policy.
Philip Sandifer comments defined anyone who disagreed with him as being "virulent hatred of transgendered people" and writers of hate speech. Such broad statements, regardless of how much he believes in it, does not bring a positive discussion.
There were worse offenders on that discussion. People who made hate speech statements, people who were extremely offensive, people who have no business in a clam, polite, and friendly discussion. And, to be extremely clear, it is a pity that the banning of Philip got lumped together with those people. The two events has nothing to do with each other, other than maybe creating some mitigating circumstance for Philips defense. This defense was brought up in the arbcom case, but was not considered enough. Thats the story here.