2 ms·
No, the point is that if someone who's a member of an recognized marginalised group says they are offended in a way members of that marginalised group are allow
by makomk 13y ago
No, the point is that if someone who's a member of an recognized marginalised group says they are offended in a way members of that marginalised group are allowed to be offended, you have to listen and apologise.
For instance, telling a woman who's been raped by a man that she was asking for it and should stop complaining is both politically incorrect and an awful thing to do. Doing the same to a cis man is still awful, but since he's not a member of the relevant marginalized group it's actually politically incorrect to object to it under some circumstances. Likewise, telling anti-rape campaigners that they're only doing it to get revenge on the gender that raped them is politically correct if they're male victims and politically incorrect if they're female ones.
Similarly, if a woman who's been raped by a man is using her experiences to advocate for rape prevention campaigns aimed solely at men, it's an attack on her personal experiences and therefore politically incorrect to question the merits of her campaign. On the other hand, if a woman who's been raped by a woman is calling for campaigns that include women, even though she's a member of the right group that's not an appropriate use of her experiences and so she's fair game for everything up to and including deliberately triggering her PTSD to get her to shut up.
Decency and empathy barely enter into it.
- arrrg 13y agoFuck off MRA.