6 ms·
The Devil Is in the Digits: Evidence That Iran's Election Was Rigged
- jgrahamc 17y agoFor a counterpoint: http://www.jgc.org/blog/2009/06/last-digits-analysis-of-uk-and-iranian.html http://www.jgc.org/blog/2009/06/last-digits-analysis-of-uk-a... Use more detailed results from the Iranian election and you don't see this effect.
- cousin_it 17y agoThanks, that comment looks much less fishy than the original article. I wonder whether the Washington Post authors tried to run their test on past known rigged and non-rigged elections. If not, that would be a good idea.
- Tichy 17y agoWhy does it look less fishy - because it contains charts? Or strange words like "chi-squared" that signify a high level of competence?
- mbreese 17y agoThis is actually pretty poor statistics. They are basing their entire argument on ~100 provincial results. The deviations they are talking about with this few number of samples isn't likely to be significant.
- jgrahamc 17y agoSo how many results would make their result significant?
- mattmanser 17y agoI thought that too until I re-read the article and started trying to do the math myself. They sum it up nicely but it's too easy to miss: "The probability that a fair election would produce [these number distribution disparities] is less than .005. In other words, a bet that the numbers are clean is a one in two-hundred long shot." Key thing to take away from the article if you're going to perform election fraud, use a computer to produce your random numbers.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- Retric 17y agoThe problem with that assessment is the more tests you do the larger your chance of finding something odd. In isolation you can look at the odds for 17+ and 4-, but two <5, or two > 16 would also look odd. As would a single >20 or <4. And, they started looking at 2 digits but the pattern is only in the last digit so there are looking at 3 groups. PS: Also how did you calculate the odds? A single number of 17 or more increases the odds of a number of 4 or less. I am not really sure how you would calculate the odds outside of a simulation.
- praptak 17y ago"The probability that a fair election would produce [these number distribution disparities] is less than .005." Careful with that reasoning. Suppose there are four candidates, and the last digits of their total vote counts are 8,7,2,8. Fewer than 1 in 9999 fair elections would produce a vote count with exactly those digits! Does this mean that the vote was rigged? Post-factum searching for (perceived) oddities and calculating probabilities of their occurences in uniform distributions shows some misunderstanding of statistics.
- otto 17y agoThe probability that a fair election would produce [these number distribution disparities] is less than .005. How did they calculate this probability. I can see what they did in other spots, but this number seems to come out of nowhere to me.
- berntb 17y agoYou can't prove anything, but can make probability arguments. This is all academic. Even the Guardian Council has admitted that there were more voters in 50 areas than eligible to vote. http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/23/world/middleeast/23iran.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/06/23/world/middleeast/23iran.ht... Also note: "But many districts where the excess votes were recorded are small, remote places rarely visited by business travelers or tourists, analysts said" And so on, problem after problem. I dare say, the next election there will be "handled" better... :-)
- alyssumclimbs 17y agoI wonder if the first digits comform to Benford's Law. Basically, the first digits of the vote counts should be 1, 2, 3 much more often than they should be 7, 8, 9 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benfords_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benfords_law
- brown9-2 17y agoFivethirtyeight.com took a look at this, and found some oddities: http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/2009/06/karroubis-unlucky-7s.html http://www.fivethirtyeight.com/2009/06/karroubis-unlucky-7s....
- bcl 17y agoI think this article from 538 does a much better job covering the subject than the original one, who's methodology is questionable.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- thras 17y agoIndeed. It's quite non-intuitive, but the naive assumption that the last digits are randomly distributed is simply wrong. Here is a V.I. Arnold essay about Benford's Law: http://www.math.ru.nl/~mueger/arnold.pdf http://www.math.ru.nl/~mueger/arnold.pdf
- riffic 17y agoAt this point it doesn't matter if it was rigged or not. The regime has voided the social contract with the people of Iran and is therefore illegitimate.
- cousin_it 17y agoThe question whether the election was rigged matters for the same reason that the question of Iraq's WMDs mattered: this information is influencing Western public opinion and government decisions right now. Also, going "it doesn't matter 'cause you're bad anyway" whenever someone calls attention to the substance of your accusations strikes me as a bad faith tactic.
- ellyagg 17y agoHa. To be blunt, I don't think most folks on Hacker News are thinking about this in good faith. If some other country this community doesn't like a priori, say the US, killed a bunch of its citizens after an election, there'd be zero chance everyone here would be rationalizing away statistical improbabilities in the election results. > Others have pointed to the surprisingly poor performance of Mehdi Karroubi, another reform candidate, and particularly in his home province of Lorestan, where conservative candidates fared poorly in 2005, but where Ahmadinejad allegedly captured 71 percent of the vote. If, for example, Broward County had come up 71% for Bush in an election, that would have been considered proof of election fraud around here. In this case, it's rationalized away. Poof.
- dant 17y agoI don't think the argument is that "you're bad anyway". Regardless of who you are, how you got into that situation and whether the protesters have a point, with a protest movement that big and motivated your options are same: crush the protests, re-run the election or form a unity government. If you choose to crush the protest then you give up the "government by consent of the people" type contract that you have with society. I think it's that fact that will drive western opinion more than the actual legitimacy of the result.
- deleted 17y ago
- DannoHung 17y agoUh, forgive me if this doesn't make any sense, but why would the numbers of the actual votes be generated fradulently? Wouldn't it be easiest to say, "Okay, Ahmadi is going to win 57% to 65% in all reporting districts," and so on and so forth and then use those fractions and the known eligible voter numbers to come up with the actual counts? In which case, shouldn't we be looking at the last digits of the percentage of votes won by district?
- chairface 17y agoWell, the thing about percentages in an election is that a lot of them don't _have_ last digits. Further, if the percentages came out to nice numbers like 57% and 65%, we wouldn't even be having this discussion - it would be really, really obvious.
- DavidSJ 17y agoThere are a number of causes for caution here, such as the possibility of publication bias. There could be 100 other statistical tests that the election passes, but who would publish those boring results? Another problem is how reasonable the null hypotheses are. Should we really expect Iranian vote counts to fit Benford's Law in a fair election, for example? I don't know. I have no reason to believe the election was fair, but I think any scientific results reported directly in news media without peer review a week after a very controversial election are highly suspect.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- WilliamLP 17y agoThis article is pure shit. Anyone with a reasonable math education should know why, and should know about data mining. That you can get away with such things in major newspapers is simply shameful.
- gojomo 17y agoI hate to be a credentialist, but I would have more confidence in this analysis if it came from statisticians rather than political scientists.
- caffeine 17y agoThe statistics is completely wrong - and the conclusion is (probably) completely right...