5 ms·
You make a fair argument for changing copyright law to better reflect today's reality without undermining the motivation for having the law in the first place.
by Silhouette 13y ago
You make a fair argument for changing copyright law to better reflect today's reality without undermining the motivation for having the law in the first place.
I don't think someone has much right to complain if they blatantly violate the law as it stands today and then get minimally called on it, though.
- rwmj 13y agoSo he's going to change the law to make copyright terms reasonable? No. He should persist in civil disobedience (and of course be prepared to take the consequences).
- Silhouette 13y agoAnd face a $150,000 claim for statutory damages for the wilful infringement? It's easy for a general to consider the optimal strategy for storming a fortified position. He's not going to be the cannon fodder who gets sent in first with little chance of survival.
- dragontamer 13y agoHell, its not just Copyright law. Trademark law says that you're not allowed to use another company's Brand. Without proper Trademark law, it is impossible to build up a "trustful" relationship between a company and its customers. You are NOT allowed to copy another person's brand that they have spent many years and much money developing. Its just not fair.
- throwaway98604 13y ago> Without proper Trademark law, it is impossible to build up a "trustful" relationship between a company and its customers. I disagree. This can still be achieved with the right (non legal) infrastructure to protect your brand i.e. an official Twitter account or domain name that can be used to identify the "legitimate" products from a company. It would be a much better tradeoff to the current cannibalistic nature of our current trademark laws that cripple the development of truly wonderful games like Pokemon Generations [1] while they milk the brand to death by regurgitating the same game with new Pokemon year after year. [1] http://www.indiedb.com/games/pokemon-generations/news/change-of-pace-updates-rescheduled http://www.indiedb.com/games/pokemon-generations/news/change...
- dragontamer 13y agohttp://www.bitlaw.com/internet/domain.html http://www.bitlaw.com/internet/domain.html Trademark law protects you from domain camping and false identities.
- throwaway98604 13y agoIsn't Trademark a form of domain camping, too?
- dragontamer 13y agoDomain Camping is when you look at another person's brand and say "I like their brand, lemme pretend to be them". For example, "camping" the site "microSSoft.com" would be domain camping. Trademark law requires you to provably build a brand from the ground up. Hire your own artists, hire your own creativity. Are you honestly telling me that you are so uncreative that you can't create your own brand? Don't recreate "Mario", create your own damn characters! And that is how the world gets better: when you reward creativity. It is virtually impossible to recreate a character, a brand, or anything and actually violate trademark law if you actually built a brand from scratch.