2 ms·
Well, as I understand it the subsidies result in direct draws on the Federal fisc by the insurers, and the latter can't afford to wait till the next calendar ye
by hga 13y ago
Well, as I understand it the subsidies result in direct draws on the Federal fisc by the insurers, and the latter can't afford to wait till the next calendar year to get paid. And there's certainly a desire to avoid fraud given that schedule of payments, if I'm correct about it.
Erk: if you're right about estimates and it depending on that years tax return; what do you do if you lose your job and can't afford to pay the unsubsidized rate? What if you earn a lot more money, spend too much of it, and then get hit with a huge bill next April 15th?
I'm disabled and on Medicare so I haven't been looking into these fine details ... this all sounds unworkable to me at first glance, unless it's retrospective based on ... the last year's tax return, but, erk, can't do that either since that don't be doable before the mid-December deadline necessary to get you into a insurer's system.
WTF???
ADDED: this probably explains why the Federal system has to do this, access to IRS payments data (e.g. withholding) is required, it's sensitive data and only they have all of it. Although Experian has a income verification role (people without credit, like sick young adults who can't leave the nest are at last count thoroughly screwed because the Federal site isn't handling this manual intervention well or at all), but I assume that's a double check. Maybe not? Maybe they couldn't get that info out of the IRS's generally high latency (often weeks and months, sometimes years) computer systems?
- tanzam75 13y ago> And there's certainly a desire to avoid fraud given that schedule of payments, if I'm correct about it. But why is it any different than the desire to avoid fraud through underwithholding of income tax? If someone files an in incorrect W-4 and underwithholds by $2000, then the Treasury is out $2000. If someone files a fraudulent insurance application and gets $2000 of unwarranted subsidy, then the Treasury is also out by $2000. It's the same $2000, whether the Treasury writes some checks to the insurance company, or fails to collect it from an individual on his paychecks. Either way, the $2000 gets paid back on the tax return -- or the IRS goes after you. > Erk: if you're right about estimates and it depending on that years tax return; what do you do if you lose your job and can't afford to pay the unsubsidized rate? What if you earn a lot more money, spend too much of it, and then get hit with a huge bill next April 15th? Again, not different in principle from income tax withholding. If you do not withhold the right amount, then you may get hit with a big bill or receive a big refund when you file your 1040. The main difference is that the subsidy does not automatically adjust. Withholding tends to automatically go up and down with income, because it's calculated by the employer on the paycheck. Whereas the insurance subsidy stays constant unless you make changes. If you lose your job, you're supposed to tell the exchange so that you can get a bigger subsidy. If your income goes up, you're supposed to tell the exchange so that you can get a smaller subsidy.
- hga 13y agoThe big difference in the first point is who collectible the debt is. Someone who underwithholds has to have that money in the first place to do so. Sure, they may have spent it, but it suggests an ability to earn money commemorate with the debt incurred. With insurance subsidies, scamming "insurance" companies can sign up nonexistant people etc. and collect those payments from the Treasury until someone catches on months or years down the road. Hence the need to reconcile everything in one central system. In the case of individuals committing fraud, many would do so simply because they can't pay the higher premiums now demanded of their subgroup (there's a lot of cost shifting), so you have more of a "can't get blood out of a stone", and the optics for the IRS are horrible. For your latter point, you're saying you make a 2013 enrollment based on partial 2012 data, and if you've got your act together you adjust with healthcare.gov or the linked state site as things change. Which I'm familiar with, the quarterly payments for those who don't withhold ... but I bet this'll hit a lot of people who aren't used to this sort of thing, but the automatic withholding of income that HR/ADT/whomever does for your paycheck....
- tanzam75 13y ago> Someone who underwithholds has to have that money in the first place to do so. Sure, they may have spent it, but it suggests an ability to earn money commemorate with the debt incurred. ... With insurance subsidies, scamming "insurance" companies can sign up nonexistant people etc. If you claim an undeserved subsidy, then that means you earn too much for the subsidy. Which means you earn enough to pay for healthcare. You may want to spend it on something else, like your mortgage. But then we're back to the underwithholding situation. The Social Security Number prevents subsidies from being claimed for nonexistent people. It's like the "phantom dependents" problem on income tax returns. When the IRS began requiring an SSN to be provided for each dependent, the problem went away. I'm not convinced that fraud would actually be a major problem. It's not like you get the whole year's subsidy at once. You get it a month at a time. Instead of running the income-check interactively, run it as a batch process after the first month of coverage. Then investigate the most egregious cases -- either individual or insurance company fraud. If an insurance company is committing fraud, take it out of next month's subsidy payments. Remember -- we're already trusting these insurance companies to provide a whole year's worth of coverage, until the next open-enrollment period. They're around to be accountable.