5 ms·
>“To me, it’s a huge problem,” said Bradley S. Shear, a lawyer specializing in social media law. For one thing, Mr. Shear told me, colleges might erroneously id
by pmiller2 13y ago
>“To me, it’s a huge problem,” said Bradley S. Shear, a lawyer specializing in social media law. For one thing, Mr. Shear told me, colleges might erroneously identify the account of a person with the same name as a prospective student — or even mistake an impostor’s account — as belonging to the applicant, potentially leading to unfair treatment. “Often,” he added, “false and misleading content online is taken as fact.”
This is the bit that troubles me. In fact, a similar phenomenon nearly cost me a job while I was in grad school. I applied for a position with the CS department, and my future boss had received some emails from a guy with the same first and last name, but different middle initial that were, let's just say, quite unprofessional. It's only because I was told and given the chance to point it out that I got the job.
I could probably have lived without the job in this case (it was only a 20-hour a week student job, after all), but what if it weren't? My name is common enough that unless you know something about me beyond first and last name, you won't find me on the internet. I'm practically John Smith (not my real name, obviously).
- sillysaurus2 13y agoIn high school there were a number of bullies I would've gotten revenge on by trashing their names with social media. I wonder if it could be made a crime? It may not be possible to criminalize it, since it's usually accidental rather than purposeful. Therefore social media seems a dubious metric under any circumstances. And yet it works quite well for YC to filter out potential applicants. So there are some circumstances in which social media provides signal. Maybe making it impossible for someone to forge your identity is the way forward. It's certainly an uncomfortable thought that all future children will be judged by what they say as young teenagers, though. But maybe it's inevitable. They'll just have to mature more quickly. Adolescence is an artificial invention anyway.
- bad_user 13y agoPeople are also quick to jump to conclusions. Twitter/Facebook are awful mediums for expressing your thoughts within the proper context, so somebody that doesn't know you and hasn't followed you doesn't necessarily have the right context to judge you based on 200-chars messages or based on funny pictures or whatnot you end up sharing. Therefore, at least give the guy the chance to explain those posts.
- tedunangst 13y agoDeliberately impersonating someone with the intention of damaging their reputation may fall afoul of some slander/libel laws.
- anonymous 13y agoI highly suspect that impersonating someone online fall foul of the CFAA.
- pcrh 13y ago> I wonder if it could be made a crime? Unjustifiably trashing people's names is already a recognized offense, it is called "slander" or "libel", depending on whether it is spoken or written. There are two defenses to this, one that the comments were 'fair comment", i.e. not malicious falsehoods, and the other is "freedom of speech". These defenses are variously successful in different jurisdictions. In the UK, for example, it is very hard to defend yourself from an accusation of libel, since you have to prove that what you said was factually correct, which is of course easy if that is the case, and you have proof to hand. However if a good lawyer reduces your "facts" to mere hearsay, and then you are in trouble. In the US "freedom of speech" usually trumps everything else, and you rarely get into trouble for lying about another person.
- WalterBright 13y agoA lawyer once told me that to win a libel/slander case, you needed to show: 1. that the statements made were false 2. that the person making them had malicious intent (i.e. they knew the statements were false and weren't simply joking) 3. some demonstrable harm I.e. saying "Fred is a jerk" isn't slander, because that's a statement of opinion, not a fact. Saying "Fred is a thief and a drunk" is a statement of fact.
- jacques_chester 13y agoDefamation laws vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction; the advice your lawyer gave in your situation is not necessarily applicable to all situations. Some jurisdictions have allowed the common law (which itself is particular to jurisdictions and so can evolve in different directions in different places) to govern it, others have legislation, still others have a mix of the two. In particular, truth is usually a complete defence to defamation, but not always. Sometimes it is only a partial defence and sometimes it is not a defence at all.
- legutierr 13y ago> And yet it works quite well for YC to filter out potential applicants. How so?
- sillysaurus2 13y agoI can't find the original announcement of Startup News right now, but one of the reasons this site was set up was to gather intel on potential applicants. Your comments tell them a lot about your character, which they use in decisions about whether to accept applicants or not. HN is "social media," so that's an example of the effect we were talking about.
- darklajid 13y agoSorry for derailing this, but I love the fact that you're using 'John Smith, not my real name' while having (probably?) your real name as a handle here. Even better? There's a pmiller and you're pmiller2..
- asdfologist 13y agoWell it's not like he's trying hard to hide his name. If you google his email address, the first result is his github page which contains his real name.
- pmiller2 13y agoNo, I'm not trying to hide it much at all. So you found my real name, email address, and github account. With all that, you could probably find my Linkedin account, which will tell you where I've worked and where I went to school. But all that stuff is practically public information, anyway, and I make no effort to hide any of it. But that wasn't actually my point. My point was that starting with just a name, you're going to end up with precisely nothing about me. Even knowing my email address and everything on my LinkedIn page doesn't get you really anywhere. What you find ends up being a lot of info on people who are clearly not me. I'm pretty effectively hidden in plain sight.
- chrismonsanto 13y ago"I'm practically John Smith" means "I have a common name". He wasn't trying to hide his identity.
- Aloha 13y agoI'm gifted and cursed with a very very common name, it's in the top 20 of male first/last combinations. I've had trouble with flying because of it, I've had some difficult explaining to do when some overly broad background checks come back (matching on first/last/DOB), problem with collection agencies, and the usual problem of it being impossible for any agency to find me by first/last (a double edged sword). It's frustrating but its also a shield, so long as no one can bridge the gap between my real name and the nickname I use online, I'm safe from this kind of digging, I feel sorry for those who're not.