3 ms·
Ask HN: A thought
When the internet first started, it was designed to be a distributed network with no single point of failure. Email, the web, and so forth, had all started as distributed.
But what typically happens is that a single "website" shows up and gets the majority of people on it, and everyone gets hooked on the centralized versions of what was originally designed to be hosted and run by anyone with enough experience.
Email -> hotmail, gmail, yahoo mail
Personal sites -> myspace, facebook
D V C S -> github
Even experienced coders enjoy using the centralized tools on github.
Why is this? And what are the pros and cons of centralization? Perhaps centralization uses less computing power and is more efficient in many ways including implementing best practices for all users, but it also has a single point of failure and suffers from numerous problems of politics, that manifest themselves in limited ability to manage privacy controls / plugins etc. as well as one central place where governments can hook into / intimidate. The second problem (of privacy and sexurity) might not be solved by having lots of little hosts, but the problem of personal control and customization can, as well as the problem of bottleneck, or monopoly / having to pay, etc.
Thoughts?