4 ms·
It's all about the linking of one thing to another. If you browse news.ycombinator.com without ever registering, a site admin viewing access logs doesn't reall
by meowface 13y ago
It's all about the linking of one thing to another.
If you browse news.ycombinator.com without ever registering, a site admin viewing access logs doesn't really have any frame of reference for the IP address. It's just a random visitor. They could also see your browser and OS, but that is not even remotely unique or descriptive about you as a person.
On the other hand, if you sign up with a personal e-mail address, a site admin could realize that some "5.5.5.5" IP making unusual requests is also "john.smith@gmail.com", and infer further things about you based on that.
The same goes for if your emails are leaking your IP address unbeknownst to you. So, for example, someone you are emailing will be able to quickly know your country, region, and potentially your city; you may or may not desire that. If you attend a university or are working at a company's premises, they will know what university or what company. If you sent the email from a coffee shop, they will know the shop's company's name and a rough location, and could infer the precise location based on that.
For a personal email like "jim@mit.edu", this isn't a concern, but if you perhaps have an email you use when you want to remain anonymous or semi-anonymous on the internet, often you won't want that kind of information disclosed.
And from a security perspective: if you are hosting some kind of a server from that IP address, it could be scanned or attacked. And whether you are hosting anything or not, the email recipient could try to launch a DDoS attack against you (typically in the form of pure bandwidth saturation).
- nitrogen 13y agoThey could also see your browser and OS, but that is not even remotely unique or descriptive about you as a person. Well, there is this: https://panopticlick.eff.org/ https://panopticlick.eff.org/
- meowface 13y agoYep, quite true; though users of HN would expect admins not to implement such invasive features. In the event that a site does, though, even if they acquire a completely unique fingerprint for you as a site user, they still don't find anything interesting about you yourself. If you visit the same site with the same IP and never register, they won't be able to put that fingerprint to much use. Now, if that fingerprint were shared with or collected by other providers in some way (perhaps by a common ad network), much more nefarious things can be done in that regard.