3 ms·
It would cost a lot more than $40 million to majority-attack Bitcoin. I estimate $3-4 billion or more. Mostly data center costs. Let's assume an attacker is ve
by mrb 13y ago
It would cost a lot more than $40 million to majority-attack Bitcoin. I estimate $3-4 billion or more. Mostly data center costs.
Let's assume an attacker is very good and needs only 6 months to design his own ASICs and build data centers to host the farm. The network is at 4 Phash/s today, so 6 months from now we should be around 4 * 2^6 = ~250 Phash/s (the network has been doubling in size every month for the past 10 months). The best ASICs, 28nm KncMiner, are approximately 100 ~Ghash/s and 100 Watt each. So an attacker would have to build 250 Phash/s of these to clearly outperform the network: that is 2.5 million chips at 250 megawatt total. And to plan for a potential delay of 30 days in his plan, an attacker would have to build not 250 Phash/s but 500 Phash/s of ASICs to attack the network. 5 million chips. 500 megawatt data center. For comparison, Facebook spent $210 million on their 28 megawatt Prineville data center. So a 500 megawatt data center would probably cost $3-4 billion. Even the well-funded NSA couldn't get their comparatively punny Utah data center to run correctly and it has been delayed by more than 1 year: http://www.pcworld.com/article/2052960/nsa-data-center-suffers-meltdowns-is-delayed-by-a-year-report-says.html http://www.pcworld.com/article/2052960/nsa-data-center-suffe...
Is China seeing Bitcoin as a threat? No. And even if it was, is it big enough for them to be willing to spend $3-4 billions to destroy it? I don't think so.
- tptacek 13y agoBitcoin. It might work, as long as no large government in the world decides to make it stop working.
- mrb 13y agoGovernments cannot stop Bitcoin on a global scale for the same reason they cannot stop Internet on a global scale. There is no cost-effective way to destroy a well-designed decentralized technology/protocol, plus it would require co-operation of most countries to destroy it.
- tptacek 13y agoYou mean, unless they buy enough asics.
- mrb 13y agoDid I not demonstrate in a back-of-the-napkin way that it is out of reach of the NSA ($3-4 billion & deploying 500 megawatt within 6-7 months)? If the NSA cannot do it, no government can.
- eli_gottlieb 13y agoNever call something impossible when there are political and financial points to be scored by doing it.
- bpicolo 13y ago$3-4 Billion is nothing for China. If they want to destroy it it's totally trivial. Besides, I bet they can cook up more efficient devices than commercially available asics.
- mrb 13y agoTrivial? Let's assume attacking the Bitcoin network would be a project falling in the hands of the most well-funded Chinese government agency: the military. (It would not, but let's assume it). This represents about 3-4% of their annual budget (~$100B), which is not quite insignificant.