3 ms·
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_tank#Placement_and_safety http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_tank#Placement_and_safety There have been a lot of problems with
by stcredzero 13y ago
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_tank#Placement_and_safety http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fuel_tank#Placement_and_safety
There have been a lot of problems with fuel tank placement, with some designs being responsible for spraying passengers with flammable fuel, which subsequently catches fire.
The design criteria for internal combustion cars seems to be to place the energy storage such that it minimizes the chance of damage, and to take steps to ensure that the contents do not endanger the passengers. Gas tanks are not designed to withstand highway speed collisions with pointed steel objects and never burn. To apply such standards to electic cars is a double standard.
By the general standards of passenger cars, I'd say that the Tesla model S is a bit fragile, but still quite safe.
- 001sky 13y agoI'd say that the Tesla model S is a bit fragile, but still quite safe What's fragile about 6mm armour plate? And what's safe about 100% of the fires having a single source? It sounds like TSLA needs to put the battery somewhere more protected. They have it exposed right now (presumably for lower CoG and better handling). That might just be a design flaw. I think we can still keep an open mind on LiIon untill the designs are iterated upon more.
- stcredzero 13y agoWhat's fragile about 6mm armour plate? Urgh. Nice context switch. To be fair, the system as a whole seems to be a bit fragile, which is what I was actually saying. But in this specific strawman context: Lots of things are "fragile" when a piece of steel has a significant fraction of the momentum of a car behind it. To me, still very dependable and robust for something with sportscar performance.