4 ms·
> You are certainly lucky that your natural interests lead you to something lucrative There is certainly luck involved, but chalking all success up to fortunat
by humanrebar 13y ago
> You are certainly lucky that your natural interests lead you to something lucrative
There is certainly luck involved, but chalking all success up to fortunate nerd-dom is a simplification. Also consider the importance of avoiding pitfalls like drug abuse, crippling debt, and unexpected pregnancies. Also, millions of students do boring and pointless schoolwork every day to improve their grades so they can get into a good college, not because they were born with the "I like dioramas" gene. Calling success luck diminishes that brand of responsibility and hard work.
- _delirium 13y agoIsn't Valley culture pretty much the opposite of what you describe, for better or worse? Classic engineering culture does have some of those features: work hard at school, get good grades, get into a good college, work hard in college, do an internship, graduate with a good GPA, get a good white-collar job. Valley startup culture seems to sort of hate that culture, though, and considers it a kind of obsolete old-people culture that needs to be (wait for it) disrupted.
- humanrebar 13y agoI certainly hate go-along-to-get-along culture. For the record, I would love to see the need for crap work be disrupted. I'm just saying that for the time being, some boring responsibility is necessary even in Silicon Valley (large swaths of QA come to mind) and hardly anyone (no one?) is lucky enough to like all of it.
- prostoalex 13y agoAnd yet everybody hires from Stanford or CMU.
- randomdata 13y ago> Also consider the importance of avoiding pitfalls like drug abuse, crippling debt, and unexpected pregnancies. Wouldn't avoiding those things largely fall under the "certain type of person" I mentioned? There are certainly some variables there too, like being born into poverty, but we can, for argument's sake, assume outside factors are otherwise equal when comparing people under this.
- humanrebar 13y agoI understand your point, but I'm pushing back on it because I don't agree that those other factors are trivial when discussing poverty and inequality. To ignore personal behavior in this discussion is to be begging a false cause fallacy. At some level we may just disagree about how fair it is to consider us all fleshy robots and how important it is to consider individuals instead of populations.
- randomdata 13y agoI'm afraid I do not understand your comment as you seem to be echoing what I have stated.
- humanrebar 13y agoOK. Let me rephrase. Hopefully it will clarify. I'm saying ignoring behavior like the ones I mentioned for the sake of argument leads to fallacious reasoning with respect to the causes of (and probably the solutions to) poverty and inequality. You could chalk decisions up to DNA and brain chemistry, but at that point we're having a metaphysical argument. You could say that we should be considering trends in populations and not individual behavior but then we'd be having another philosophical discussion. Or maybe you agree with all that and I'm misunderstanding your point.