3 ms·
That may be true in some respects, but things like refrigerated shipping, ambulances, sanitation (cars do not defecate in the street), and modern logistics have
by humanrebar 13y ago
That may be true in some respects, but things like refrigerated shipping, ambulances, sanitation (cars do not defecate in the street), and modern logistics have both saved lives and decreased the cost of essentials, even for the car-less urban poor.
I'm also skeptical that the balkanization of modern postal codes could be a result of the car. I currently hypothesize that that it is a result of postmodern influence on social structures, but it's surely a complex phenomenon in any case. To throw the blame for this across the hood of a car is an oversimplification at best.
Finally, while urban areas are more segregated by class, the quality of life across regions has largely improved across the board. It used to be that only people in cities had access to professional medical care, law enforcement, electricity, and running water. Now, every log cabin in the woods (even if it is inhabited by people of color) has a toilet that flushes and a phone to call an ambulance with. I don't think the development of the automobile is unrelated to this development.
- rayiner 13y agoMy point of course isn't that cars are uniformly bad, or even bad on the whole, but rather that they've had a major negative influence on a certain part of our social structure that cannot be ignored. We've gained much in terms of convenience and safety, but we've lost something real. A kid growing up in a suburb can go years without seeing a poor person or a homeless person. All those benefits of cars are real, but so too are the social consequences. I'm not a luddite, but I'm not a believer in glossing over the social challenges created by technology. Recognizing those problems doesn't mean necessarily adopting an interventionist approach to solving them, of course.
- humanrebar 13y agoFair enough. I'll agree with all that. That being said, I still don't believe cars have universally detached people from each other. While it's easier to ignore your neighbors, people out in the country have access to more things (including cultural institutions like museums) and certain types of travel (road trips) have broadened horizons in other ways. I'm also not sure how much of the changes in our social structure are due strictly to technology as opposed to shifting attitudes about family, home towns, social clubs, mass media, and other social institutions.