4 ms·
> Smart software... is ushering in an era of "hyper-meritocracy." > ...the cognitive requirements of working with smart software... > Online education... will
by crazygringo 13y ago
> Smart software... is ushering in an era of "hyper-meritocracy."
> ...the cognitive requirements of working with smart software...
> Online education... will only deepen inequality... Because of the premium it places on conscientiousness. some people are pure self-starters... But at the same time, I think it’s a pretty small percentage of the population.
These are all excellent points.
It's funny -- centuries ago, when there was no meritocracy, if you stayed poor, it probably wasn't your fault. You were born a peasant, and there really wasn't any way out of it. Some people argue that it made for happier people. (And if you were rich, it wasn't because you were really smart or capable, you were probably just born into aristocracy.)
But the kind of ruthless economic meritocracy we have today is much less forgiving, as your shortcomings are made so much more obvious. If you're the kind of person who enjoys reading programming manuals and studying Fourier transformations for fun, then you'll probably have a great career ahead of you. But that's just not the case for most people.
- pradocchia 13y agoSome day, when the AI systems take over, and the world no longer needs so many people that enjoy reading programming manuals and studying Fourier transformations, the great bulk of programmers will be lined up and shot, in retribution for their years of pampered arrogance. And it won't be the people we put out of work, it will be the people who paid us, who will have long since had enough of it.
- nathan_long 13y agoI find your comment bizarre. A baker doesn't spend $X on flour unless she can make more than that from selling the bread. Companies don't pay programmers big bucks and give nice benefits unless they make a lot more off the software programmers build. Nobody is getting ripped off here.
- ceejayoz 13y agoI think the point was that you don't see many bakers bloviating on web forums about how merit-worthy they are.
- nathan_long 13y agoI don't see programmers saying "I'm a superior human." I see them saying "I know I can make $X elsewhere, so I'm clearly not going to accept less than $X here." I believe bakers do the same thing, for smaller values of $X.
- ForHackernews 13y agoWhat a joke. What you've written could be said of any well-paid job right up until it's eliminated: "Telegraph operators were paid well and felt themselves part of an honored profession. It was a good way to make a living for a lot of people."[1] Companies would be THRILLED to eliminate developers and no longer have to pay them. And plenty of people are working on that problem: "Imagine sitting at a Salesforce event in 2008 in Chicago while Salesforce.com’s CEO, Marc Benioff, swiftly works an entire room of business users into an anti-software frenzy. I was there to learn about Force.com, and I’ll summarize the message I understood four years ago as 'Not only can companies benefit from Salesforce.com, they also don’t have to hire developers.'"[2] [1] http://www.appalachianhistory.net/2010/06/3918.html http://www.appalachianhistory.net/2010/06/3918.html [2] http://programming.oreilly.com/2012/10/salesforce-developers-acquisitions-investment.html http://programming.oreilly.com/2012/10/salesforce-developers...
- nathan_long 13y agoSure, if companies could do without paying programmers, they would and should. That doesn't change the fact that they continue doing so (at least for now) because they see it as a good deal. Programmers are responsible for continuing to have skills that are marketable if the economy changes. >> "right up until it's eliminated" This phrase implies an Evil Power is deciding who gets to live or something. In reality, a job is "the opportunity to meet a demand by selling labor." It's not unjust to stop demanding something. When people stopped wanting top hats, that wasn't unjust, even though it meant hat-makers needed new jobs. If people stop wanting software, it won't be unjust, even though it will mean programmers need new jobs. I'd love for my house to produce its own electricity so that I could fire the power company, but until that seems easy and cost-effective enough, I pay for power because I think the money I spend gives me outsize benefits. Same with my employer paying me.
- thedufer 13y agoFrom 2 comments up: > the great bulk of programmers will be lined up and shot, in retribution for their years of pampered arrogance. _This_ is what your parent finds "bizarre". Are you arguing that the same would be said about any other job that was eliminated by changing market conditions? No, that would be insane. They lost their jobs and found a new line of work (or fell into poverty). And that's what will happen to programmers if (when?) our job is eliminated.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- VMG 13y agoBut the programmers will have encoded preferential treatment for their class into the AI. Checkmate unmeritants.
- _delirium 13y agoI'm not sure how this really relates to merit or shortcomings or being your fault. I'm good at technology, and I make money at it, but I don't see this as a particularly great merit or the result of my hard work and prescience. I've liked and been adept with computers since I was 4 or 5; I'm "the kind of person who enjoys reading programming manuals" you mention. I'm no good at drawing, though, and I'm not particularly skilled at face-to-face interaction with people. It just so happens, through nothing of my own doing or foresight, that programming computers is, at least today, a more lucrative skill than realistic sketching or good retail service are. If the opposite had been true, I would be paid less and a number of other people would be paid more, through no change in our own skills. I see it more as a matter of alignment: my strengths currently align with market demands. This is not something I predicted when I developed those strengths. As a kid I, perhaps naively, didn't think playing around with computers was even a real thing you could do as a job. Partly that might've been because the people I looked up to and read stuff by didn't seem to be doing it as a job (e.g. the author of a typical 1990s Phrack article). I assumed when I grew up I would have to get a real job, doing proper engineering, or carpentry, or accounting, or something.
- randomdata 13y agoYou are certainly lucky that your natural interests lead you to something lucrative, but you are good with technology because you presumably spent considerable amount of time practising with the technology. If you spent more time drawing, you would eventually become good at that too. If we imagine technology jobs dropped off the face of the earth tomorrow and drawing suddenly became a high paying career, would you invest the time and effort required to become good at drawing, or would you rest on your innate interests and watch your job opportunities fade away? That is the distinction the parent appears to be making. The tools are available to become good at just about anything you can imagine, but it requires a certain type of person to push towards that goal when the natural curiosity is not present.
- _delirium 13y agoI guess it depends on the degree of need. If I were starving and had no choice but to take up drawing as a career, I guess I would try. But if technology were still something you could make $40k/yr doing, I'd probably stick with it, because it's more interesting to me. I'm in technology for the technology more than for the money. In some ways I kind of wonder if it'd like it more: what would technology as a field be like if the $100k+ jobs and big exits were gone, and the people who were here primarily for the money therefore lost interest and went elsewhere? I think that's reasonably common. I can't think of people I'd consider "highly meritorious" technologists who have no strong like of technology, and picked the field just because it was a good career. In fact may of them picked the field in a previous era, when it wasn't as lucrative of a career. I think many people who are good at and interested in something have fairly high "stickiness" to it, so salaries tend to track the rise and fall of the fields, more than the merit of individual people, who don't switch fields that easily or quickly. It's in that sense I'm skeptical that salaries are a good indication of "merit". They're just an indication of what they literally are: the current relationship between market supply and demand for a specific skill. This may even related to all kinds of structural issues, e.g. quick spikes in demand coupled with slowly responding training pipelines may cause high salaries in an area to persist for a decade or two, but this has more to do with the training pipeline's slow response than the existing workers' high merit. (And similarly in reverse.)
- codemac 13y ago> [..] your shortcomings are made so much more obvious. If you're the kind of person who enjoys reading programming manuals and studying Fourier transformations for fun, then you'll probably have a great career ahead of you. But that's just not the case for most people. This made me chortle a bit. True, there are some nerds in ghettos across the world, but I doubt they have safe shelter, food, water, and a half decent education. If you can't fucking read, it doesn't matter if you're the "type of person that enjoys reading". I think poverty is a HUGE reason why African American's aren't highly represented in tech. Or hell, West Virginians.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- AndrewKemendo 13y agoI think you overlook the still overwhelming amount of impact your early upbringing causes on later life. Being born poor and living in poverty has the biggest impact on long term health due to both restrictions in linguistic development and brain health from a poor diet. There was a study recently that reinforced that poverty was the #1 determinant of long term educational attainment. It's too far a bridge to say that we are increasingly economically meritocratic, if anything some of the "meritocratic" tools we have are only benefiting those that can afford being outside of the mainstream.
- larksimian 13y agohttp://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats.htm We're at less than 50% global internet penetration. How many of those people without internet have access to programming books and computers? The only reason being a self-starter is so important is because of how trash CS(/math/engineering/stem) education is, globally, and because, unlike the other STEMs, self-teaching programming doesn't require expensive equipment. Online education will almost certainly not deepen inequality edit: among the 30% of the world population that has access to computers and a safe, healthy childhood since it will allow people to skip the real barrier to entry in software engineering: dreadful professors and boring, overwrought courses at expensive to attend institutions.
- normloman 13y agoThere's more barriers to entry in software engineering: Free time to teach yourself code, an attention span not used up worrying about gangs, drugs, or crime, a mind unencumbered by undiagnosed mental health problems worsened by poverty, social connections that can actually get you a job in software.
- sanskritabelt 13y agoIf the current situation were in fact a meritocracy, wouldn't we expect to see a lot more social mobility than we're seeing now? (http://www.brookings.edu/research/reports/2013/06/13-facts-higher-education http://www.brookings.edu/research/reports/2013/06/13-facts-h...) (http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/03/17/social-immobility-climbin_n_501788.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2010/03/17/social-immobility-c...)
- thedufer 13y agoParent was comparing the meritocracy of today to the lack thereof centuries ago. I don't see where either of those links looks farther than a few decades back.
- sanskritabelt 13y agoI was giving evidence against the claim that we live in a meritocracy.
- svachalek 13y agoIf you're the kind of person who enjoys reading programming manuals and studying Fourier transformations for fun, you have a solid middle income career ahead of you, and if you take some chances you may even hit a minor stock jackpot somewhere along the line. Which is great, just don't confuse that with being an investment banker.