3 ms·
For those who think this is a bad thing, consider that "unlimited" most often means "limited in an opaque way you cannot control". This cap and pricing structur
by IgorPartola 13y ago
For those who think this is a bad thing, consider that "unlimited" most often means "limited in an opaque way you cannot control". This cap and pricing structure adds some very nice clarity to exactly when you might exceed you quota. Personally, I would rather pay for the extra GB's than get my connection throttled at the end of the month.
Pricing May or may not be acceptable to some, but the model itself is better than "we will limit you if we feel like it".
- Dwolb 13y agoThis comment assumes Comcast cannot provide unlimited data and clarity, which I believe could be a better option.
- IgorPartola 13y agoQuantify unlimited. Do you literally intend to saturate you connection 100% of the time? At what speed? Would you prefer they do not meter your traffic at 10Mbps or they give you 200 GB at 100 Mbps? The simplistic view of GB/month doesn't work well for power users.
- Dwolb 13y agoIt's not in my knowledge how to quantify unlimited. Any definition of unlimited should come from the provider, Comcast.
- IgorPartola 13y agoIf you cannot define what you want then do not ask for it.
- Dwolb 13y agoThe comment wasn't seeking any type of solution. The response pointed out a flaw in the original, unedited comment.
- guelo 13y agoBullshit. This is monopolistic abuse by a rent-seeking monopoly that should be broken up.
- IgorPartola 13y agoWould you rather have them cut off your internet access entirely when you watch too many episodes of Breaking Bad in a row? I will agree that most ISP's are fairly evil, but I would rather know where I stand with them than just get a notice that I am cut off for no good reason.
- hashtree 13y agohttp://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/be_on_the_horns_of_a_dilemma http://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/be_on_the_horns_of_a_dilemma
- gamerdonkey 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/False_dilemma Thinking that those are your only choices is a prime example of why the broadband market needs far more competition. ISPs do not operate like electric utilities where they generate gigabytes to send down the line to your house. ISPs spend money on building capacity to transfer data, which they then sell to their customers in chunks. If they cannot provide they capacity they sold to their customer, it should not be the burden of the customer to avoid exceeding that capacity.
- IgorPartola 13y agoThey are not the only choices, but I have never seen an ISP implement any other. I am not saying this is a ultimate solution to the ISP stranglehold on consumers. I am simply saying that this solution is better than the other common one.
- ghshephard 13y agoIf Comcast simultaneously were to commit to a 100% neutrality policy regarding the serving of that data, and would also commit to not traffic shaping - I.E. For my $50 a month, I would get a non-screwed-around-with-by-their-traffic-shapers 50 megabit/second stream - I might agree with you. Unfortunately I suspect we will get both - a data cap, and Comcast will continue to screw around with your traffic feed so they can profit off the front end and the back end (charging for enhanced access to their customer) - basically screwing the customer in both directions.
- IgorPartola 13y agoAgreed. This is not the only required step. I am actually mostly concerned with minimum guaranteed bandwidth and latency than anything else. Working from home means that I need a reliable connection more than anything. However, from what I have seen of all the different providers I had and researched, "unlimited" traffic is usually a very bad thing when you least expect it.
- ghshephard 13y agoAs someone who has dealt with telecommunications providers (Sprint, AT&T, Verizon) for the last 10 years on a professional basis, "Unlimited" is ALWAYS a code word for "There is a level that if you go over, bad things will happen to you, from traffic shaping, to outright cancellation of your account." Honest to goodness conversation with Verizon I had in 2005 (we were purchasing about 100 M2M (Machine to Machine) CDMA circuits) - it was Pythonesque in its tortured logic. Me: So, I'm wondering how much traffic we can use? Sales Guy: They are totally unlimited Me: Great, so how much is "Totally Unlimited?" Sales Guy: Just what it sounds like - No Limit. Me: Right, but what is the actual Limit. Sales Guy: It's unlimited. Me: So, I can stream 100 kilobits/second continuously for 32 gigabytes/month/circuit: Sales Guy: No, that would fall under our unapproved usage clause. Me: Yes. I understand. So, I'm wondering how much traffic we can use?
- shmerl 13y agoThis model is completely idiotic, since they have no need to limit any data at all. The only reason for limiting can be if their network is overloaded with traffic. And then data caps are pointless either, they need to ration bandwidth, not the amount of data per month to solve it. And even that is not a proper solution, if they have network congestion, they need to build up their network, that's it.
- IgorPartola 13y agoThey pay for the traffic per GB you use. It is minimal but in the end I imagine it makes a difference whether the average user uses 300 GB or 300 TB.
- shmerl 13y agoDo they? Do you mean to the higher level networks? I doubt the amount they pay has a significant impact that mandates them to introduce data caps. Here is a review of the issue: https://secure.dslreports.com/shownews/Cable-Industry-Finally-Admits-Caps-Not-About-Congestion-122791 https://secure.dslreports.com/shownews/Cable-Industry-Finall... In practice, data caps is an anticometitive junk devised by the cable networks to raise the price for those who stream video over the Web. It would be proper for example to require to split any ISP business from any kind of video / TV service, since they have clear conflicts of interests there which have negative effect on user experience.
- ghshephard 13y agoUnlike what a consumer might pay on AWS for traffic, large ISPs almost always typically pay for the size of circuits at the 95th percentile. They do NOT pay for traffic per GB you use for circuits that fall below that peak circuit size - there is zero cost to any ISP for actual usage - it's peak usage. And, even then, peering makes pricing even more opaque, in which Tier-one providers negotiate mechanisms in which they agree to exchange traffic at zero cost, and just set up connections in meet-me rooms. Regardless, The parent is right - cost is not a function of data sent, but a function of peak circuit size for the ISP - so, if there is a period in which there is little usage of their network, the ISP can serve traffic at close to zero cost to themselves.
- axus 13y agoIt's a step in the right direction. Comcast already cuts people off who download "too much" too many times. It used to be that "too much" was undefined, then it became 250GB. The necessary next step is other internet providers competing on speed + cap. People can compare to an expensive LTE plan capped at 5GB, and make an informed decision. When there is FIOS at the same speed with no cap, or a 1Gbps uncapped provider, people have a real choice.
- tallanvor 13y agoI could _maybe_ get behind you if they were charging a reasonable price when you go over the cap, but $10/50GB? That's insane! Given the rates I pay for extra transfer on my dedicated boxes from my provider, Comcast will make well over $9.50 for each extra block they sell.