4 ms·
Not that this exonerates Toyota in any ways, but if your car is accelerating out of control, why not just take it out of gear (ie. put it into neutral)? Or hav
by Mikeb85 13y ago
Not that this exonerates Toyota in any ways, but if your car is accelerating out of control, why not just take it out of gear (ie. put it into neutral)?
Or have they removed that ability from newer automatic transmissions? (my last few cars all have manual transmissions)
- drbawb 13y agoOn most new cars: the transmission is entirely computer controlled. This is the case for "semi-automated manuals" like DCTs as well as automatics. For e.g: to shift to neutral or disable a Prius at speed you have to "hold" the shifter in the neutral position [note: it doesn't seem to stay there like it would on a traditional automatic gear selector; it's spring loaded] or "hold" the ignition switch for 3-5 seconds. This is (presumably) to prevent the motor & trans from grenading itself. I haven't driven a vehicle newer than model-year 2003 recently: so in a panic situation I would expect my cars to make the "money shift" and blow up their powertrains; not "ask me for confirmation" that I want to destroy my motor. Having to wait to make a money-shift seems like a feature that looks excellent on paper, but terrible in practice. I find it difficult to buy a car which only has firmware-implemented kill switches.
- rlanday 13y agoIs this common, that an automatic transmission won’t immediately shift to neutral? I thought that automatic transmissions usually let you shift to neutral without pushing the shifter button in to let you shift to neutral without blowing through it at trying to put the engine in reverse. Shifting into neutral while driving shouldn’t break anything, unless maybe if the throttle is fully open and the rev limiter isn’t working, but that’s the most important situation for being able to shift into neutral, isn’t it? I don’t see why an engineer would want to try to prevent this.
- dmm 13y agoThe Prius doesn't have a tradition automatic transmission with a torque converter and multiple gear ratios. The gas engine is connected to the wheels at a fixed ratio along with two motor/generators in a planetary gear system. Reverse is achieved by running the electric motor in reverse. There is no reverse gear. Shifting the neutral on the prius just means disconnecting the MGs and turning off the ICE.
- fearlessleader 13y agoBecause in manuals you have a physical link between you and the gearbox (usually), Almost all modern automatics simply have an informational link. If the computer freaks out and doesn't accept the message, no change.
- Mikeb85 13y agoSo strange... Old automatics always had a sort of physical connection in which you could pop them out of gear in an emergency.
- tonyarkles 13y agoThis is one of the reasons that I love manual transmissions. Sure, you'll probably still blow up your engine, but that's way better than dying. One of the interesting things from one of the other articles was related to depressing the brake. Apparently one of the solutions to resetting the out of control acceleration was to completely remove your foot from the brake before trying to brake again. This may sound curmudgeonly, but that is one of the reasons that fly-by-wire makes me so uncomfortable. In my car, the accelerator is attached to the throttle by a cable, and that's the way I like it :). I was driving my girlfriend's 2010 Pontiac Vibe the other day (essentially a Toyota Matrix) and stopped at a slippery intersection. When I went to get going again, the traction control system detected that it was slippery and, as far as I can tell, did throttle limiting to prevent the wheels from slipping. This is one of the most uncomfortable feelings I've ever had driving a car... I pressed the accelerator and there was no response.
- Mikeb85 13y ago> When I went to get going again, the traction control system detected that it was slippery and, as far as I can tell, did throttle limiting to prevent the wheels from slipping. This is one of the most uncomfortable feelings I've ever had driving a car... I pressed the accelerator and there was no response. Most decent cars let you disable the traction control (which is necessary sometimes)... But yes, sometimes the newer technology doesn't work as well as the older technology, depending on the conditions and driver skill. I've had ABS kick in a few times and it's really disconcerting, I almost prefer not having it. Traction control is great for tiny patches of ice or rain, but terrible when the roads are covered in fresh snow. My old Saab 900 Turbo was the best winter car I'd ever had, could basically plow through anything the front bumper could clear (and never failed to start - even when it was minus 40 degrees). My new car is adequate, but not nearly as good when it gets really ugly... And fly-by wire IS scary, they should never eliminate physical connections for certain functions (accelerator, brakes, steering).
- tonyarkles 13y agoThe ABS in my car lost a sensor a few years ago and shut itself off. I see it as a feature :) There's a way to disable the traction control, but figuring it out wasn't what I had in mind while stuck at a 4-way stop.
- ken_railey 13y agoAlso not trying to blame the victim, but it seems the even more obvious/natural approach would be to use the brakes. Those are hydraulic, and plenty powerful enough to counteract any force generated by a Camry's engine.
- owenmarshall 13y ago>Those are hydraulic Are they hydraulic from the brake pedal to the brake pad, or is the brake pedal just a software input to a brake control system? From one of the other articles on the Camry unexpected acceleration issue, emphasis theirs: "Vehicle tests confirmed that one particular dead task would result in loss of throttle control, and that the driver might have to fully remove their foot from the brake during an unintended acceleration event before being able to end the unwanted acceleration". The natural approach seems to cause as many problems as it might otherwise fix!
- ken_railey 13y agoThe brake pedal actuates the master cylinder, which is connected hydraulically to the calipers. Even if stomping on the brakes triggered more throttle problems, they are still plenty strong enough to stop the wheels from turning.
- angersock 13y agoAh, but what about anti-lock brake systems?
- dmm 13y agoAnti-lock brake systems work by reducing hydraulic pressure at a wheel that is determined to be slipping. It doesn't affect how braking is activated.
- angersock 13y agoA little black box regulates the applied pressure due to criteria X. I submit to you that if X is buggy, the little black box may decide never to allow pressure to hit the brakes. This in turn prevents braking.
- ksrm 13y agoMy instinct would be to turn the engine off.