4 ms·
Not all of us can be l33t hax--er, security researchers. But we can do some basic meta-analysis. Aside from some of the transmission vectors like ultrasound aud
by bitwize 13y ago
Not all of us can be l33t hax--er, security researchers. But we can do some basic meta-analysis. Aside from some of the transmission vectors like ultrasound audio stretching plausibility (even in ideal environments, acoustic data transmission is a royal, error-prone bitch), there is the simple issue that a non-POC piece of malware this insidious should have arisen in multiple sites with multiple analysts looking at it. Instead, it's just Dragos. The other researchers with an interest in badbios are all saying "listen to Dragos and pay attention because he's awesome." What they should be saying, if the badbios claims hold up, is "holy shit, I've got it too, everybody seal your computers in concrete until we figure this out!"
I'm not doubting Dragos's awesomeness; I'm doubting how much bearing his awesomeness has on the truth value of the badbios narrative. The press getting wind of this and turning it into a sensational story didn't help.
- Amadou 13y agomalware this insidious should have arisen in multiple sites with multiple analysts looking at it. Stuxnet was floating around the net for about a year before there was public discussion. It was only afterwards that people went back and realized that something had been there all along. Part of the problem with expecting people to notice this class of viruses is that they are not malicious, don't use excessive amounts of resources and are deliberately designed to be stealthy. They aren't a general purpose bot-net, they don't target anyone's bank accounts -- in short they have the lowest possible profile that a well-funded and well-managed engineering organization can come up with. From that perspective, the only odd sounding behavior is that infected systems avoid booting from anything but USB drives. That's a little high-profile for this class of virus. It isn't enough for me to dismiss Dragos's claims, but it is incongruous with the assumed design goals.