6 ms·
Wow, the government brings in a program to genuinely try and help people, and the people want to tear it down because it "violates their rights". America you s
by grecy 13y ago
Wow, the government brings in a program to genuinely try and help people, and the people want to tear it down because it "violates their rights".
America you so crazy.
- VonGuard 13y agoThis comes from a very concerted effort by highly placed folks in the US (Koch Brothers, health care companies). Essentially, they create fear and confusion around the new laws through Fox News and dial-in radio, and American idiots eat it up like it was the Bible truth. The people in this country who are against the health care law, uniformly, know nothing about it and regurgitate Fox News BS when asked why it's a bad law. Thing is, the law has its issues, but the other side never gets near them, they just make shit up "death panels" and government interference and stuff. I, as an American, am super embarrassed by all this. It doesn't help that the health care companies wrote the fucking law, anyway... now they're fighting against it! The sad truth is, unless we have a single-payer, socialized medical system, none of these changes will help much. Really, the biggest change the new law enacts is that it forces health care companies to cover people with pre-existing conditions like Diabetes and heart disease. Right now, they can tell you to go away, they won't cover that stuff. IN 2014, I hear they'll be forced to at least offer you a psychotically expensive plan if you have diabetes.... Ah, this country sucks ass.
- dllthomas 13y agoI respectfully disagree - I think the biggest change the law enacts is the cap on the MLR. Telling insurance companies they have to cover those with pre-existing conditions doesn't make them want to cover those with pre-existing conditions, it just makes them not want to be sued for one more thing. That is no kind of motivation to keep costs down or provide decent service - if Joe Sicko says "screw this, I am going to your competition" they break out the champaigne. With the MLR cap, having one more person means they can take home more money, so long as they're operating near the cap to begin with.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hershel 13y agoAccording to webmd, plan rates will only depend on age: "" Q: Will there be a limit as to how high a premium insurance companies can charge if you have a pre-existing condition? A: Yes. As of 2014, insurers cannot charge consumers different rates for health insurance because of health status or gender. You can be charged more for your age, however, with older people paying a higher premium than young people. But that increased charge is capped at no more than three times the standard rate"[1] Edit: Actually "The law allows for differences of premiums based only on four criteria: age, location, family size, and smoking."[2], which seems like a good way to do racial profiling and increasing premiums on poor people(since they're probably less healthy), as expected in the u.s, but at least pre existing conditions couldn't be a basis for a rate difference. I wonder thought how legal would be doing data mining with this information (an other free datatbases) , and how much deanonimization could be practically achieved ? [1]http://www.webmd.com/health-insurance/health-reform-insurance-for-pre-existing-conditions http://www.webmd.com/health-insurance/health-reform-insuranc... [2]http://ahip.org/Issues/January-1-2014-Provisions.aspx http://ahip.org/Issues/January-1-2014-Provisions.aspx [1]http://www.webmd.com/health-insurance/health-reform-insurance-for-pre-existing-conditions http://www.webmd.com/health-insurance/health-reform-insuranc...
- IanDrake 13y agoI don't think I fit your description of those who don't like the ACA, but I don't like it none the less. I believe we could fix health care costs by removing just one law. Stop making health insurance a tax deductible employee benefit. Think critically about the effect that small change would have and you'll see why our system is broken.
- dllthomas 13y agoWhile I totally agree with your proposed change, I don't think that fixes the system as a whole - especially if it were the only change to the pre-ACA state of affairs.
- lewispollard 13y agoAs an interested non-American, how would that change the system?
- IanDrake 13y agoIn the US, if your employer pays for your health insurance, they pay for it with pre-tax dollars. If you buy it, you buy with post tax dollars. That's why employers pay for it in lieu of paying you more. If your employer pays for your car insurance as a benefit, they pay for it with post tax dollars, so they don't do that. So, employers pay the premium on your health care for the tax advantage. Now consider the how psychology behind not being the one who pays for the premium. Do you care how much your services cost? No. Do you care if the premium goes up? No. Do you shop around for better insurance? No. Do you care if you loose your job if you're sick? Hell yes. In effect all normal market pressures are gone. No one who consumes resources cares about their costs because they're are completely disconnected from paying them or some derivative of them. This is why doctors don't post prices. While the net effect for people with employer provided health insurance is ever increasing rates, the effect on those people without health insurance is brutal. They are trying to enter a market that has no price pressure.
- lewispollard 13y ago
- jeremyt 13y agoI love how you make baseless accusations directed at the "Koch brothers" based on an article that doesn't even say that there were actual denial of service attacks. Then you poke fun at "American idiots", and then admit in your last sentence that you don't really even know how the law works yourself. Bonus points for picking the two conditions, heart disease and diabetes, that mostly result from poor choices instead of random innocent victims. Your whole post is like a parody of pseudo-intellectual liberalism.
- jack-r-abbit 13y ago> a program to genuinely try and help people That part is still very much open for debate.
- ctdonath 13y ago“Of all tyrannies, a tyranny sincerely exercised for the good of its victims may be the most oppressive. It would be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated; but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.” ― C.S. Lewis Yes, classic American culture tends to take rights violations very seriously, to the point that it may baffle those used to living under tyranny. Yes, many of us have a problem with the government commandeering the healthcare of 100% of the population just to "help" 3% of the population. Would have been cheaper, and far less disruptive, to just buy that 3% health insurance outright.
- kaoD 13y agoUnless the rights violations target communists, terrorists or atheists.
- nate_meurer 13y agoThat's a great quote, but poorly applied in this case. The financial crisis we will face in the absence of effective reform is of concern to more than just the "moral busybodies". Obamacare has problems, but being targeted to just 3% of the population is not none of them. Are you completely free from anything that an insurance company might call a pre-existing condition? Do you plan to never be unemployed? Of so then congratulations, you might not personally benefit from healthcare reform of this type. Most Americans are not in that boat. Certainly more than 3%.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoOr it would've been cheaper to enact price caps on healthcare services and eliminate for-profit insurance companies, to replace them with single payer.
- natmaster 13y agoPlease explain how doubling everyone's monthly premiums so that health care 'businessmen' can make more money helps the American people.
- mhurron 13y ago> doubling everyone's monthly premiums [citation needed]
- bananashake 13y agoI, a self employed entrepreneur, was rejected for healthcare. Maybe now I'll be able to get it as soon as they fix their website. So they got that much right. In the meanwhile, I am perfectly healthy and will look both ways before crossing streets.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- ihsw 13y agoThe Patriot Act was all about fighting terrorists, right? Right?
- Mikeb85 13y agoTo be fair, the way Obamacare is implemented is crazy. They should have just gone with full-on socialized health care like the rest of the civilized world... Would have been better for every party involved (except perhaps the insurance companies).
- grecy 13y agoBut we know that would never have passed. I've always thought of ObamaCare as the first step in the right direction. Hopefully many more steps follow shortly.
- ctdonath 13y agoA plurality of the population doesn't want full-on socialized health care. Those insisting on making it happen anyway concocted this crazy implementation as a means of squeezing something thru in that direction, quite possibly in hopes that the fallout would make "single payer" the only viable option. Yes, we're not "like the rest of the civilized world": this country was founded on valuing individual rights above the whims of the majority.
- Mikeb85 13y agoSo you'd rather your government spend money on the NSA, TSA, wars on terrorism and drugs and a thousand other programs that inhibit your freedom than to ensure that the poorest, most vulnerable members of society have access to free health care?
- ctdonath 13y agoThat's an amazing non-sequitur. ETA: just because I'm opposed to one program doesn't mean I favor others. I'm just as opposed to "NSA, TSA, wars on terrorism and drugs and a thousand other programs" as I am to Obamacare. I'm not sure how you conclude that by opposing wasteful oppression in one area somehow means I'd be more tolerant of wasteful oppression in other areas.
- 13y ago
- wpietri 13y agoI agree 100%, but let me see if I can explain their view (which I disagree with) in a way that will make sense, or at least seem less crazy. If you're an open-source participant, you may have experienced the power of what I've heard called adhocracy or do-ocracy. In it, we're all equal individuals; power is used situationally, in a bottom-up fashion, by those who are currently accomplishing something for the common good. In those contexts, top-down exercise of power feels very interfering. The US's history includes a strong dose of that, plus a strong sense of individual liberty. Our country was born in rebellion to some far-away people who wanted to boss us around. Almost everybody here is descended from somebody who said, "Fuck this country; I'm outta here," and moved to America. One of our central civic documents, the Bill of Rights, basically lists all the things the federal government can't do. A giant chunk of our national mythos is bound up in westward expansion, where in a thinly populated frontier, the cowboy-hero did what he wanted and bowed to no man. Never mind that the era was short and the story more complicated; it's the idea that lives on. Most of us who live in cities have long ago accepted the need for modest civic organization and collective action. We live too close to one another to be able to pretend that every man is an island. But even here, we tend to jealously guard our independence. Much more so in the suburbs and in rural America, where interdependence is harder to see. Given all that, a demand that you buy health insurance can easily seem like (or be made to seem like) a crazy imposition from a far-off bureaucracy. Most other tax in the US is based on income, assets, or expenditures; if you aren't making/owning/spending anything, you don't have to pay. To some this feels like being dragged into participation in a society that they never particularly wanted to be part of. All of that is intensified by several factors. A big one is the Republican party's strong shift rightward [1]. There is also a large segment on the right that has decided that the black guy with the funny name is not an American [2], making anything he does seem more like an imposition. Plus, there's a long tradition [3] of painting this as "us" (that is, white people) paying for "them" (black and brown people), even though the federal government actually shifts a lot of money from liberal states to conservative ones [4]. There are also strong streaks of anti-intellectualism and fundamentalist religion that play into this. All that said, I agree it's kinda crazy when you take the bigger picture into account. America's health care system is a mess, costing way more than anybody else's, and leaving millions with little or no service. Something has to be done. This solution was actually a conservative one [5], and it's not like the American right has proposed anything better. It's not the solution I would have picked on my own, but given current American politics, I think it was the most achievable option. Ok. That's more than you every wanted to know about America. Thanks for making it this far. [1] http://voteview.com/images/polar_house_means.png http://voteview.com/images/polar_house_means.png [2] e.g., http://www.ocregister.com/totalbuzz/obama-469434-http-href.html http://www.ocregister.com/totalbuzz/obama-469434-http-href.h... [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Southern_strategy [4] http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/08/americas-fiscal-union http://www.economist.com/blogs/dailychart/2011/08/americas-f... [5] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patient_Protection_and_Affordable_Care_Act#Legislative_history http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patient_Protection_and_Affordab...
- beauzero 13y agoI haven't seen much "genuine" or "try" out of either party lately.