3 ms·
The survey illustrates a great point about how many conceptions the public has about the worlds are totally wrong. I don't want to detract from that, but I have
by Houshalter 13y ago
The survey illustrates a great point about how many conceptions the public has about the worlds are totally wrong. I don't want to detract from that, but I have a minor criticism about the whole "worse than chimpanzees" thing. I think they picked these questions knowing or at least having an idea that the majority of people would get them wrong. It's not hard to design a survey that gives you whatever results you want if you can pick any questions at all. Manipulating the multiple choices (contrasting the good answer with opposite extremes for example) might also have an effect.
The projection of children by 2100 doesn't seem accurate. Yes population growth is declining but after 3 to 4 generations of exponential growth, wouldn't populations with a high cultural or biological tendency to reproduce more be vastly over-represented by then?
- bzbarsky 13y agoBirth rates are dropping in pretty every high-birth-rate population, even ones with very strong cultural/religious tendencies to reproduce (e.g. http://forward.com/articles/139391/in-israel-haredi-and-muslim-women-are-having-fewer/ http://forward.com/articles/139391/in-israel-haredi-and-musl... is a good example that surprised me). I'd be interested in what populations you think have high birth rates, will continue to do so, and how big those populations are...
- Houshalter 13y agoI don't know what specific populations have higher birth rates, but any individuals with a greater tendency to reproduce are going to be selected for heavily and pass along their cultural tendencies as well.