4 ms·
I wonder if Google will ever end up in legal trouble for such a policy. While I don't support the notion that any company or person should have to support any v
by freehunter 13y ago
I wonder if Google will ever end up in legal trouble for such a policy. While I don't support the notion that any company or person should have to support any version of OS or browser, knowing the massive effect that Google has on the web market and the fact that they have their own browser, if there is any attempt to specifically lock out older competing browsers, the FTC or EU might have questions about that. If you're pushing to be number one in a massive market, you have to play by different rules (as Microsoft found out in the 90's).
Google hasn't been playing nice with Microsoft for a while (see how many Google apps are in the Windows Phone store, the issue where they locked out IE Mobile from viewing Google Maps, or how they treat Windows Phone trying to interface with YouTube). In a way it's nice to see Microsoft reaping what they've sown so long ago, but in another way it's incredibly frustrating from an end user perspective to be someone who likes Microsoft software (such as Windows Phone) and also enjoy using Google services like Maps and Youtube.
Google should be careful with how much they're pushing against Microsoft, especially with Microsoft's new market position versus Google. Microsoft is hardly the monopoly anymore.
- davidjgraph 13y agoThis market if office software, and web enabled applications. Microsoft most certainly are the closest to a monopoly in office software, how many companies buy Word simply to open files sent to them?
- barake 13y agoWell hopefully zero, since Microsoft gives away free software to view Word docs (plus other apps for Excel and PPT): http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=4 http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/download/details.aspx?id=4 In practice, I'm sure lots of copies are sold for the reason you stated.
- angularly 13y agoGoogle is doing the world a big favor with this, forcing people to upgrade to new browsers and defragmenting the web as a whole... not to mention making life a hell of alot easier for all us web developers. Microsoft can just make their browser autoupdate like everyone else is doing.
- emn13 13y agoBut if they don't, ironically, google may be helping microsoft by encouraging users to upgrade their PC. And there's no sign that MS will ship new browsers to old platforms.
- teisman 13y agoOf course, users can also simple adopt a modern browser, rather than updating their system. Additionally, if Microsoft doesn't support modern browsers for old operating systems this may deteriorate the Windows experience, which may lead to desktop/laptop conversions to Ubuntu.
- louthy 13y agoXP has 6 months life left, after that I suspect most 'enterprise' web app developers will drop support for IE9, I know we certainly will be.
- angularly 13y agoDo you mean you'll drop support for IE8? XP never supported IE9 as far as I know.
- eli 13y agoI think (hope) most people are making those decisions based on actual analytics data and customer needs versus maintenance cost. I still get a fair bit of IE7 traffic, and there hasn't been a "good" reason to run that for quite a while.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> if there is any attempt to specifically lock out older competing browsers If its not current, I'm not sure that it is "competing" in the sense that would normally be relevant in antitrust/competition law.
- quink 13y agoAnd that would very quickly end up with the question of whether all this isn't greatly Microsoft's doing by dropping IE support for older versions of Windows.
- dangrossman 13y agoGoogle doesn't have monopoly power in the office or e-mail hosting markets, so nothing they do with their apps product can be an abuse of monopoly power. You don't have to play by different rules until you have that power, not while you're aspiring to it. They're not pushing #1 in the browser market either for that matter. Chrome is running on around 1 in 3 devices, and has been losing share to Internet Explorer the past few months. http://www.w3counter.com/trends http://www.w3counter.com/trends http://gs.statcounter.com/ http://gs.statcounter.com/
- Adirael 13y agoThe problem with IE9 was released two years ago, it's last update was more than a year ago and I don't think it will get any more updates that are not security updates (I don't have time to look now but the updates it got were probably just security updates).
- ahoge 13y ago> I wonder if Google will ever end up in legal trouble for such a policy. Why would they? On what basis? Also, even Microsoft doesn't want anyone to support old versions of IE. Microsoft wants to sell Windows licenses, remember?
- JohnTHaller 13y agoIE is 58% of the global desktop market, so monopoly rules would not apply. Google similarly locks out old versions of Chrome and Firefox as well due to not supporting modern CSS3/HTML5/JS standards. Remember, Google isn't locking IE out at all. Both IE10 and IE11 will continue to be supported. Google's stated policy is to support the current and prior major release of all supported browsers (IE, Firefox, Chrome and Safari). Microsoft itself has a similar policy of only supporting the relatively modern versions in their online Office suite. They don't support IE8 but do support IE9. That means Windows XP users can't use IE to access Microsoft's online office suite.
- taoufix 13y ago> I wonder if Google will ever end up in legal trouble for such a policy. I don't think so. It's not like they're banning IE9- users from accessing their services. It's just that the content will probably look weird to them.