8 ms·
I love how whenever a major world leader comes out against the war on drugs, it is always after they are out of office and generally retired from political life
by oh_sigh 13y ago
I love how whenever a major world leader comes out against the war on drugs, it is always after they are out of office and generally retired from political life.
- dman 13y agoDo you risk your career and your livelihood for your innate principles often?
- mildtrepidation 13y agoWhile I agree with this, it's exactly the reason many governments right now get almost nothing done (and what they do get done is awful): People in power who care more about their job security than their -- or anyone else's -- principles. A politician's career should be based on reconciling principle with reality. Their livelihood should be linked directly to their ability to do this successfully. That comes with a certain level of idealism, true, but without that we have to concede that our lives are in the hands of people we don't even expect to care.
- rayiner 13y agoIt's more complicated than that. Politicians have a limited amount of political capital, and in American politics even getting little things done requires spending a lot of it. Obama put up some huge numbers and ultimately spent all his political capital just doing two things: 1) getting us out of Iraq; and 2) passing the Affordable Care Act. Ending the drug war is important to some people, but there are tons of people who support the drug war for moral reasons, on both sides of the aisle. Meanwhile, with an aging populace people are much more concerned with Medicare, Social Security, healthcare, pensions, etc, than the justice or injustice of the drug war. Even a politician who does care sincerely about ending the drug war wouldn't waste his political capital actually doing it, not in face of all the more important things that people want done.
- proksoup 13y agoSupport the drug war ... for moral reasons? That mother showing pictures of her 4 missing boys in the article this thread is about, I think she would argue the war is immoral. I think the people who think the drug war is moral, would change their mind if they spent more than 30 seconds thinking about it. Baffles my mind, and when pressed in person, even pious blowhards admit there are serious violent death problems with their methods --- but the people who support them seem totally oblivious to the violent oppressive death that their war causes. How the fuck is it a moral war?
- rayiner 13y agoNot everyone has the same system of morals. A lot of people, probably most, think that bad behavior is socially contagious. It's a premise that is not exactly divorced from reality. E.g. I would certainly be at least concerned if my daughter's friends were drug users, because I do think children and adolescents can pick up bad habits from the people around them. To these people, the possibility of drugs raises the threat of personal danger to their families. Some people further think that bad habits like drug use can be controlled through legal means. I don't think they believe it can be eliminated, but I think they believe that if we did not have a drug war, drug use would be a lot more common. Furthermore, those people can justify the damage caused by enforcement on the grounds that it happens to people who bring it upon themselves, by participating in drug use and drug trade. Even this proposition isn't totally divorced from reality, at least within the U.S. There is lots of collateral damage, but by and large the people dying in gang wars are involved in gangs to begin with, and the people in jail for drug crimes did use or deal drugs. You don't have to agree with any of this to concede that these ideas are rooted in some sort of moral framework. Not a particularly compassionate moral framework, but there is nothing about moral frameworks that requires them to be compassionate.
- proksoup 13y ago"Not a particularly compassionate moral framework, but there is nothing about moral frameworks that requires them to be compassionate." My concern is, they think, and argue that their framework is compassionate --- but they are ignorant of reality and what's actually going on with their war.
- dreamdu5t 13y agoI would suggest you do concede to reality: We give control to other people at the behest of rhetoric about "getting things done" or "everything would crumble without me." We shouldn't put people "in power" in the first place.
- legutierr 13y agoIs comming out against the "war on drugs" really a career killer, still? I think some real leadership from public officials would quickly reverse the remnant of public support that exists for this so-called war.
- rayiner 13y agoYou've vastly misjudged the battlefield. Among actual voters, the drug war is still seen favorably.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> Among actual voters, the drug war is still seen favorably. Some elements of it obviously aren't, as we see marijuana legalization advancing (in some places, at least nominally, restricted to "medical" use, in other places more generally.)
- elements 13y agoSlightly OT, but spending a bit of time on Gallup's website recently has shown me much I've misjudged the popularity of a lot of attitudes.
- legutierr 13y agoI'd love to know where I could find the stats on actual support that drug war policies have. Although I'm sure that majorities exist opposing outright legalization, I think that the people who support "drug war" policies as they are currently implemented are in the minority. The way the question is posed to people can have a big effect on support. For instance, saying, "The war on drugs is counter-productive because it increases addiction rates and increases the harm caused by addiction, and should be replaced with a well-funded addiction-minimization and education regime," is different than saying, "Drugs should be legalized because adults should be able to choose for themselves what they put in their bodies." When I mentioned "real leadership" above, I meant leaders that would make a case and design an alternate policy that would convince voters who are afraid of legalization as such, but who recognize that the drug war is a failed policy.
- guerrilla 13y agoYes, but I also don't have to depend on popularity.
- netcan 13y agoI don't think that's fair .. at least not in most cases. Politician is not just a job. It's a leadership role, moral leadership among other things. Being principled is a major component of the job they've undertaken. If a doctor found a discrepancy between his career and the welfare of his patients or a judge between his career and justice, I really do think they are morally obligated to choose selflessly. Maybe it's naive, but I think it's possible to have a society where most judges are genuinely obsessed with being just.
- declan 13y agoI'd say the last place to search for "moral leadership" is among the ranks of professional politicians.
- bmelton 13y agoThe problem therein is that, at least in the vast majority of circumstances, everybody thinks that they are being "just", but their justice is always colored by their own personal morals, which may or may not conform to your morals or mine. I'm sure that the judge who recently disallowed a mother from naming her child "Messiah" felt like he was being just, but that justice was undoubtedly colored by his religious faith. The judges who uphold "traditional marriage" also probably felt like they were being just, as their justice is shaped by what they personally consider to be 'right' and 'wrong'. The law itself, in too many cases, offers too much ambiguity. We want states to have the right to do things their own way on issues we want, but not on issues we don't. If we, as people, support the right of gay marriage, we think that states should be required to allow it. However, if we support marijuana is relatively harmless, we think that states should be allowed to legalize it. These are just examples, but it's hard to come up with a 'pragmatic' solution for what is or isn't just. If justice is based on morality, then whose morality do we base it on? If it's based on whether or not it causes harm to others, then what level of harm do we allow? Freedom of speech is generally harmless, except when it isn't -- except when it's "fire" in a theater, or when it's your neighbors yelling at 3 am, or when it's someone preaching [religion/anti-religion] in contrast to what I want to hear. In short, it's a very complicated thing, justice, with blurry edges, multiple middles, and an infinite list of value substitutions that muddy the issue. Even those doing the very best things for the most noble of purposes can be considered harmful by others who are also doing the very best things for the most noble of purposes.
- Nursie 13y agoThat's exactly what politicians ought to do and exactly why politics should not be a career. Granted, Kofi Annan was not a politician in the same way as the folks I'm really aiming this comment at, but still.
- antidaily 13y agoBaby steps: plenty of politicians are in favor of decriminalizing marijuana.
- balabaster 13y agoYes, but if you decriminalize all drugs then the whole industry surrounding incarceration of all those 'criminals' that are only inside because of drugs falls to pieces. There are plenty of lobbyists on the hill that are paid to do everything they can to prevent that from happening.
- sigzero 13y agoThere is zero chance that drugs like crack are going to ever be decriminalized.
- MichaelGG 13y agoWould it need to be decriminalized if cocaine was properly sold, like it used to be? One can quite easily cook cocaine into crack if they so desire.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoIt has been established as physically addictive, so no, selling it "properly" won't help.
- chris_mahan 13y agoSo is alcohol, tobacco, and caffeine.
- drzaiusapelord 13y ago
- blisterpeanuts 13y agoI'm glad Kofi Annan is doing this. I've long felt that the war on drugs has backfired, much as the U.S. Prohibition on Alcohol did. Both efforts gave rise to rich, powerful crime syndicates that inflicted untold misery and suffering on the people these laws were designed to protect. For a fraction of the cost of drug enforcement, we could fund drug treatment facilities to help people get off meth, crack, heroin, etc., and meanwhile allow marijuana to become a taxable commodity like cigarettes. There are no perfect solutions obviously but the war on drugs has proven to be probably the worst of the lot.
- vkou 13y agoGiven that both drug prohibition and the War on Drugs both started as highly racist policies, it seems to be working as intended.
- rthomas6 13y agoI'd like to read more about this. Do you have a source for this?
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoOne random factoid, that's a favorite of mine: the Ku Klux Klan supported the right of women to vote. They did so because women voters supported temperence/prohibition. And those laws allowed them to target the Catholic Irish. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ku_Klux_Klan#Prohibition http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ku_Klux_Klan#Prohibition
- Wingman4l7 13y agoKen Burns' excellent documentary miniseries Prohibition goes over this more in-depth in its overview of how disparate voting blocs banded together to accomplish the improbable -- passing a Constitutional amendment to ban alcohol. It's also an eye-opener in revealing the historical origins of the expansion of police powers like wiretapping, and IIRC, overreaches of the Interstate Commerce Clause. Once you've watched it, it's easy to draw some very damning "learn from history of be doomed to repeat it" parallels between Prohibition and the War on Drugs at a more detailed level than "drug prohibition doesn't work, just look at Prohibition."
- willholloway 13y agoIn a far off yet inevitable future of bounty and abundance... physical and emotional pain have been edited out of our genetic code, replaced by neurochemically enhanced empathy & bliss & a lavish minimum income frees our leaders to put social good ahead of job security. Until then, we're still living primitively... in the jungle as a savage, infant race.
- wh-uws 13y agois that from a movie?
- coldarchon 13y agofrom a dystopia probably ..
- mortenjorck 13y agoGoing to guess Arthur C. Clarke, but I've never actually read any of his books.
- harshreality 13y agoEmotional pain is critical for empathy. Unless you believe in the purely rational theory of human behavior, people have to feel what will be emotionally painful for others before acting in a way that minimizes emotional pain. Physical pain is also important. It keeps you from doing stupid things that end up with you getting hurt. Both mental and physical pain can be modulated/reduced somewhat through psychological training (one form of which would be meditation). I think making pain reduction any easier could cause more problems than it solves.
- MereInterest 13y agoSounds like the Maximum Fun-Fun Ultra Super Happy People from this short story. (Page 3/8) http://lesswrong.com/lw/y5/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/y5/ It goes through the horror of what that implies.
- chongli 13y agoIt's the modern day equivalent of a deathbed conversion!
- InclinedPlane 13y agoIt's a welcome message, but Kofi Annan is one of the most corrupt and least credible politicians out there. It's a shame the message isn't coming from someone more respectable.