3 ms·
Wow, a guy working for Google said "fuck you" to the NSA. All my doubts and worries are gone now.
by adamnemecek 13y ago
Wow, a guy working for Google said "fuck you" to the NSA. All my doubts and worries are gone now.
- maaku 13y agoHe did preface it with a "I don't speak for my company".
- adamnemecek 13y agoTherefore...?
- maaku 13y agoI took your comment as being serious. Maybe my sarcasm detector needs adjustment.
- Amadou 13y agoAre you being sarcastic? For months Google's only public response was to lobby the government for permission to release stats(?) to prove that they complied with the law - nary a word of criticism for the law itself. So now that Google's own autonomy has been breached by the NSA (all above-board and legal according to the NSA's legions of loop-hole seeking lawyers) instead of just Google's users, now they are mad? I just made another post about how a lot of people are unable to imagine what its like for others to be in a situation until they themselves are in the same situation. But... I'm not so sure Google, as an organization, has fully recognized the scope of the problem here.
- adamnemecek 13y agoI was being sarcastic, yes.
- Amadou 13y agoOK. I had laugh-snort reading the discussion on that page - at one point the original author, Mike Hearn, tries to argue that ad-based services are actually a good thing for privacy. Does Kool-Aid have a google flavor now?
- enneff 13y agoYou should respond to his argument instead of accusing him of brainwashing. The latter does nothing to advance the conversation.
- Amadou 13y agoCan't. I so disbelieve in his argument that I won't sign up for G+. Besides, as Upton Sinclair was fond of saying, "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends upon his not understanding it."
- enneff 13y agoI'm suggesting you could rebut his argument here instead of just insulting his integrity.
- wzdd 13y agoHearn claimed that there are two ways to fund services: through advertising, and through direct user payment. This is wrong. There are plenty of other ways to fund services. You could fund them indirectly, through sales of another product. Think about Apple giving away its software and Web services (funded by hardware sales), or Microsoft giving away its Web services (funded mostly by software sales), or even of Google's nonprofitable services and projects (the ultimate income source here is ads, but it needn't be). Alternatively, you could accept some anonymous form of payment. Bitcoin is the obvious one, but there are plenty of others -- gift cards come to mind, and these have been pretty successful for iTunes and the XBOX arcade. Or, of course, there's cash, Bitcoin, and other less convenient or mature technologies. Finally, the argument is a little disingenuous, given Google's push, with Google Plus, to know people's real identity anyway. It is clear that "advertising = better privacy" isn't a Google goal, at the high level.