3 ms·
If you are impressed with intricate work, than you'd be more impressed with virtually any piece of software written today. 6000 parts? Programs routinely have t
by javajosh 13y ago
If you are impressed with intricate work, than you'd be more impressed with virtually any piece of software written today. 6000 parts? Programs routinely have that many object instances - and usually far more. Indeed, many programs have that many classes. When you include runtime dependencies like the OS or database, you're average application is several orders of magnitude more intricate and complex.
That is not to say that The Writer is not a unique accomplishment. It truly is - to succeed in creating something that complex in physical objects, and without the helping constraints that modern programers labor under is remarkable and laudable. But if you are a fan of intricate work, you can find much better examples in modern software (not to mention CPU design).
EDIT: down-vote me all you want, assholes.
- girvo 13y agoThe difference perhaps lies in the amount of people who it took to create this interesting artifact: 2, quite a bit less than your examples. Of course, you could easily argue that Fabrice Bellard is the software equivalent of a master watchmaker, and some of his creations would certainly be on par with this!
- ddunkin 13y agoI'm just not convinced software is that impressive, I've seen 12 year olds write 'complex software' (at least to me), they didn't sure need a lifetime of knowledge and skill to do that. Hello world might look complex on the wire when you think about the bits, but you didn't build any of those complexities yourself. This guy also didn't have the Internet to copy/paste from.
- darkmighty 13y agoThis sort of comment that makes me uncomfortable. I don't understand the insistence that everything you do has to be harder than everything else, or that this doesn't have any meaning because modern engineering is harder. You see, you should be bragging that modern programming is easier. The whole point of evolving engineering is to make things easier -- what would be modern science and engineering good for if we had to build things this complicated from scratch? People (rational people, that is) don't choose a framework or method of doing things because it's hard; in fact, quite the opposite, they obviously go for the easier ones! The merit should be -- look what I can achieve with such beautiful simplicity. It is trivial to conceive a harder way of doing almost everything. In fact, if you look at the automata shown here, almost anyone with a tiny bit of programming knowledge and some hardware knowledge could build something similar with an arduino and some stepper motors.
- javajosh 13y ago> I don't understand the insistence that everything you do has to be harder than everything else Where did I say that? Someone who appreciates intricacy should know that modern automata (e.g. software) is actually more intricate, by far, than antique automata. It's just you'd never see a documentary piece like this on a piece of software, and I think it's only because software is a) not physical, and b) difficult to visualize.
- dinkumthinkum 13y agoNo you're just wrong, it's sort of sad. This is far more impressive than so some crud application. It almost seems silly to need to defend that position. Sure, if you factor in the total sum of work and thought needed to make SnapChat possible, you have something impressive ... But that doesn't reasonably explain the complexity of building SnapChat, in fact part of the argument is that it took people building the thing you childishly deride to enable such a monstrosity in the first place. The level of technical sophistication of this engineer is much higher than your typical hipster programmer, by far.