4 ms·
I finally switched to xfce because it does things how I want, rather than how the Gnome or Unity people think I should have them set up. Maybe those are better
by davidw 13y ago
I finally switched to xfce because it does things how I want, rather than how the Gnome or Unity people think I should have them set up. Maybe those are better for end user type people, but... that's not me.
- ep103 13y agoThis is why I jumped back to kde
- nisa 13y agoYes! Switched back to KDE (Kubuntu + KDE 4.11 here) a few days ago. I'm really happy. I finally have a mature and stable system again. Unity was just to buggy for me (13.10) but KDE is really fast and stable. I don't want to sound like a shill here. I was happy using KDE 3.5 back in the day and hated all the KDE4 ideas... for anyone wondering if KDE is usable again I think it's the case (maybe it is for a few years longer - I did not bother to look). However it took me a few hours to configure the system to my needs and adjust the often stupid (IMHO) KDE defaults to sane settings. But I could without problems. Give KDE a try! XFCE / Xubuntu is to ugly and unflexible for my taste. KDE is also does not hog too much memory - without Semantic Desktop it's only about 400MB RSS (amd64) for the whole system after a clean boot. That still a lot but a little bit less than Unity and a little bit more than XFCE.
- bloodorange 13y agoI've been a hardcore KDE fan since over a decade. Of late though, I am inclined to move fully to GNOME 3. I use KDE on my laptop and GNOME 3 on the work desktop. I find Gnome 3 much more pleasant to work with and it let's me forget about many details of doing things on the desktop. Once I got used to it, it allows me to switch tasks faster and with less focus/flow loss while doing so. It doesn't have a "minimise" button by default in GNOME 3 and at first this annoyed me but now I see that I never think of the concept of mimising something in my workflow. It's one less thing to think about. I know there's a lot of hate for GNOME 3 floating around but I have tried it and I love it. I showed it to a lot of colleagues and most of them have switched to it too. I think in the next LTS release of Ubuntu, I'll switch my laptop to GNOME 3.
- kamesh419 13y agoIn the next LTS release of Ubuntu, you will get Unity and not GNOME3 by default. Unless of course you remove Unity and go with GNOME3.
- bloodorange 13y agoThere's a GNOME Remix that we must account for. It's what I have running on a few VMs at work and at home.
- sciurus 13y agoThe GNOME Remix is hobbled by Canonicals decision to stick with older releases of GNOME and GTK. Ubuntu 14.04 will likely ship with GNOME 3.8 instead of 3.12. For various technical reasons they can't just put the newer version in a PPA.
- baldfat 13y agoThe issue is that Kubuntu's default has a lot to desired compared to OpenSUSE's KDE polish or Arch Linux's vanilla KDE. I always found Kubuntu more work and less "useful."
- davidgerard 13y agoXfce is 4.x right now. I want them never to move to a version 5. Rant: http://reddragdiva.dreamwidth.org/582674.html http://reddragdiva.dreamwidth.org/582674.html All they have to do now is not fuck up. Xfce: please, just don't fuck up.
- hobs 13y ago"When people combine the words "desktop" and "innovation", I reach for my revolver." I love this quote. I don't understand why people are so obsessed with redesigning a thing that works well into a thing that clearly nobody wants EVER. Even the big boys do this WINDOWS 8 COUGH COUGH.
- gbog 13y ago> redesigning a thing that works well I really dislike this recent trend we can see in Gnome, Unity, and Google even, but one would be blind to not see the reason behind: They all try to solve the touch issue. Desktops were designed for the mouse, and this do not translate well on touch screens. One could argue there is a gap that cannot be bridged, but we should not complain that some people are trying to bridge the gap and create an interface that is working well on both screen+keyboard+mouse and touchscreens.
- tommorris 13y agoI have a laptop. I can't remember ever thinking "I want to rub my grubby fingers all over the screen". If I wanted to do that, I'd grab a tablet or smartphone. Touch is a compromise. Touch screen devices are useful because they go where proper computers don't. I can look at my smartphone at the bus stop where I wouldn't pull my laptop out. I don't see the point in wasting huge amounts of time and creativity designing these silly hybrid OSes. It's like adding a horse trap to the front of your horseless carriage.
- davidgerard 13y agoFor all its vaunted touch-friendliness (or touchiness), the evidence is that it was a couple of years before they even in fact tested GNOME 3 on an actual touch screen: http://news.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=3017371&cid=40835229 http://news.slashdot.org/comments.pl?sid=3017371&cid=4083522... Is being able to unlock the screen a "core functionality"?
- mistercow 13y agoYou're lucky that there's any desktop environment that does things how you want. I haven't found one yet, but xfce with compiz and a lot of customization gets close.
- dllthomas 13y agoI'm exceedingly happy with my ratpoison, but fully expect others wouldn't be.
- lelandbatey 13y agoFor me, I run XFCE with Xmonad as the WM. It's all sorts of awesome, letting me best use each of my screens. I've found it very customizable and awesome. What are the things you're looking for in a desktop environment?
- mistercow 13y agoBasically what I want is Unity's task switcher (I know, everyone hates it, but for me it is almost exactly how I like it), KDE's system settings, and xfce's everything else (except Thunar; but using Nautilus under xfce is easy enough).
- stolio 13y agoOpenbox plus many many hours of customization has earned me a set-up that I'm pretty happy with. It takes a while but if you have the time to think about every little piece and keybinding it's pretty fun.