6 ms·
From the sounds of it, what doomed them was pricing too low in a way that made it impossible to create higher tiers of service, and, perhaps most importantly, u
by rhizome 13y ago
From the sounds of it, what doomed them was pricing too low in a way that made it impossible to create higher tiers of service, and, perhaps most importantly, using AWS for everything. AWS bills monthly, so if in fact they were running a $35k/mo bill there, a HUGE refactor was passed by. But then again, startups don't hire sysadmins anymore.
- thatthatis 13y agoI think the relevant standard should be: focus on the core of your business, outsource everything else. If you are a photo backup company, storage is (or at least should be) part of your core. It seems like they tried to take the heroku route, repackage aws services with premium software and sell it for a premium. But forgot to charge the premium end user price.
- ghaff 13y agoAmazon regularly features SmugMug at their conferences and in case studies. I haven't looked at the specifics recently but they basically went all-AWS. (SmugMug is also a bit different from your typical consumer photo site but they are a photo storage and sharing company.)
- rhizome 13y agoSince they are a featured customer, they may also get price breaks.
- thatthatis 13y agoI don't believe smugmug is a freemium service, are they?
- dublinben 13y agoNope, their lowest tier is $5/mo. http://www.smugmug.com/features http://www.smugmug.com/features
- aespinoza 13y agoDo you think they were better off by having their own servers ? (Honest question we use AWS and Rackspace, and we feel the pain of Monthly bills as well).
- autarch 13y agoThis should be fairly easy to price out, right? I suggest you start by simply comparing the cost of dedicated hosting-provided hardware. This is the middle ground between owning your own stuff and something like AWS. Pricing out the cost of owning your own servers can be tricky since you need to account for a number of factors: * Initial cost of hardware - don't forget to include things like network switches, remote console devices, etc. - you may also want to buy something like a remotely accessible power switch so you can forcibly reboot machines * Rack space costs * Bandwidth costs * Sysadmin time to manage the hardware (you already need a sysadmin to manage things like backups, logging, etc.) * On-site remote hands if your rack host is not physically near your sysadmin But regardless, I'm pretty sure that _anything_ ends up being cheaper than AWS once you get beyond a fairly small number of servers. The big advantages of AWS are integration with other services (storage, load balancing, etc.) and the ability to spin many machines up and down very quickly. However, if you can tolerate waiting a day or so to provision new servers, dedicated hosting-provided hardware is almost certainly going to be quite a bit cheaper. You could also compare this to something like Linode. Again, you lose the ability to provision new machines almost instantly, but they are pretty quick to bring up new machines (minutes, not hours or days). They also have a number of nice integrated services like backups. Finally, you can also do some sort of hybrid setup where you have core stable services on dedicated machines but still spin up AWS instances to deal with bursty computation needs.
- rpedela 13y agoIf you just use EC2, no EBS, and reserved pricing then AWS is just as cheap as other providers if not cheaper. It is all the nice features that make it expensive. S3 is pretty damn cheap too. Of course, raw hosting costs are only part of the calculation. You have to include sysadmin time and salary.
- United857 13y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but doesn't Dropbox use AWS? (Or at least did until recently.) The two services' pricing (on a per GB basis) is within the same ballpark.
- rhizome 13y agoDropbox has received a quarter of a billion dollars in funding.
- nakedrobot2 13y agoAccording to Drew Houston at Websummit last week, they haven't spent any of that money.
- rhizome 13y agoSo all of their acquisitions and burn has come from (crunchbase caveat) ~7MM? There's some missing pieces to be sure, but suffice it to say that having that much cash in your back pocket allows a different set of considerations.
- emdowling 13y agoDrew said the same thing at TC Disrupt in SF this year. Reading between the lines: All the acquisitions and ability to pay 300+ staff without needing to touch a massive $250 million pot of money is basically telling the market (eg: Box): "We can play the enterprise game very well and have the revenue to prove it"
- driverdan 13y agoI'm sure Dropbox gets better volume pricing than Everpix did.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hbbio 13y agoI could not agree more. Running on Amazon instead of let's say OVH incurred maybe 10x costs. At the same time they probably didn't have an adequate pricing and freemium ratio and/or didn't do enough to market their good product. I could have been a customer but was not aware of everpix.
- anigbrowl 13y agoEven at 35k/mo, that's 420k/year. That seems reasonably low to me (in the sense of a fundamental operating expense, not in terms of the going rate for hosting, which I have no clue about). By contrast, look at their people costs: Total Salaries (between 6 people) $1,168,710.45 Total Payroll $1,298,819.67 Total Personnel Costs $1,411,513.53 That's about 10x their hosting expenses. Even if they had free hosting it seems like it would only have kept them going for another 2-3 months.
- emn13 13y agoBut it wasn't necessarily scalable from a business perspective, and that might not have been attractive to the investors they needed. Especially if it's true their pricing was low.
- sameer_sundresh 13y agoI don't know why the article list salaries, payroll and personnel costs as separate numbers like that. Payroll includes salaries, and personnel costs includes payroll.
- strelok1 13y agoThey were paying themselves nice salaries weren't they.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jliptzin 13y agoIs this payroll over one year? If so, that's absurd. No one should be making $200k+ in salary at a startup that still has yet to turn a dime of profit. Just shaving 10% off that number would have covered their AWS costs for another 3 months.
- sameer_sundresh 13y agoThe totals are all over 2+ years, not per year.