3 ms·
> Truth be told, if you start doing this in an equitable fashion with the goal of "punishing" bad banking behavior, you'll target a lot of lower-middle-class mo
by bradleyjg 13y ago
> Truth be told, if you start doing this in an equitable fashion with the goal of "punishing" bad banking behavior, you'll target a lot of lower-middle-class mortgage brokers from the 2008 mortgage crisis who knowingly committed fraud, which seems like an undesirable result.
I think it a very desirable result. When it came time to break up the mafia, the prosecutors didn't say "we can't get the dons right off the bet, oh well let's not bother". Getting the triggermen is both a good in itself and a strategy to both starve the organization of foot soldiers and to work up the hierarchy.
No one seems to have any compunctions about putting outright lower class street drug dealers in prison.
Specicially with respect to HSBC, there were several avenues available for criminal prosecution of individuals both low level (i.e. the actual tellers and bank branch officials who recieved the ilicit funds) and high level. Irene Dorner, President HSBC Bank USA, for example signed the 2010 consent decree with the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency[1] and could have been held in contempt of court for refusing to carry out the agreed changes. Also conspiracy and RICO don't require every member of the corrupt organization to be aware of all the details of the criminal acts imputed to the entire conspiracy.
The Justice Department had no problem securing a prison sentence for money laundering against Vladimir Kats[2] as well as lower level employees of Liberty Reserve, but I bet he didn't go to Oxford. Can't a women that looks and sounds like Dame Judi Dench in prison, that would be uncivilized!
[1]http://www.occ.gov/news-issuances/news-releases/2010/nr-occ-2010-121a.pdf http://www.occ.gov/news-issuances/news-releases/2010/nr-occ-...
[2]http://www.informationweek.com/security/government/liberty-reserve-operator-pleads-guilty-t/240163490 http://www.informationweek.com/security/government/liberty-r...
- cynicalkane 13y agoBaffling. You can't even get a Mafia don for something his hit man did, unless you can prove the don was involved. RICO isn't a license to throw people in jail because of some hand-waving about responsibility. I don't think the law works how you think it works. When you talk about HSBC officers you're talking about things probably >90% of them didn't even intend to happen, much less had any provable connection to. Even actual bad guys are hard to put in jail, never mind if this stuff about blaming bank executives for everything has any significant merit. I'm double baffled that you think the mortgage officer example--the harried guy in a cheap suit overlooking some fudged numbers here and there--is at all comparable to a drug dealer or a hit man, both of whom knowingly destroy people for a living with their different weapons. Liberty Reserve is a poor counter-example because the Liberty Reserve guys allegedly laundered billions of dollars, on purpose, provably knowing they were doing it, in fact setting up an illegal business offshore so they could do it. If the allegations are true there's no doubt they are actual bad guys. Oh, and it took a two year long international effort to bring them down. And I remember there being some HN indignation when Liberty Reserve was taken down, which is ironic when you compare how angry people are about HSBC doing much less. Imagine the response if Liberty Reserve was owned by Goldman Sachs!
- dllthomas 13y agoI think the dodgy mortgage officer is actually a pretty good match for a (non-violent) drug dealer. Both are selling something they've been told they shouldn't, to someone who mostly thinks it's in their best interest, and is ultimately profiting by (some or much of the time) hurting that person.