3 ms·
Your understanding of the points you are arguing against is so terrible and flawed that you need to start over from scratch. (Note the difference between that
by jerf 17y ago
Your understanding of the points you are arguing against is so terrible and flawed that you need to start over from scratch.
(Note the difference between that statement and "the points you are arguing against are correct".)
"He assumes that, if people have to pay their own money, they are going to make rational economic decisions about health care purchases and will shop around for the best price. This is such utter crap that it is hard to believe that an open minded economist would utter it."
The idea that people don't take prices into account is such crap I can't believe anyone could believe it. You argue:
"They are made on other considerations like trust in the doctor and increasingly on patient evaluations of treatment options."
Which betrays a profound misunderstanding of how economics work. Those considerations are indeed weighed... all in a context of how much it costs! If you can't understand it in an emotional arena like health care, consider buying a house. Price isn't the only concern. How much you like it factors in to your final decision. But if you don't consider price at all, you're going to make a very bad decision by any measure, both conventional (you're going to run out of money) and economic utility.
"Yes, I by drugs at Costco because they are cheaper, but that is because Costco has negotiating advantage, not me."
Time for some 5 Whys: Why does Costco have a negotiating advantage? Because they are big? Well, why are they big? You can dance around all you like, but you're going to have to come back to "Because they have you and many other people as customers, and Costco can aggregate your bargaining power together." If Costco screws up and alienates enough customers, they will have no more bargaining power. This is a critical aspect of economic theory. Your conception of Costco as a sort of platonic ideal of a large company, with this fact disconnected from the input of the rest of the economy, is very wrong. Costco's bargaining power is an effect, not just a cause.
I commend to you a lot of time with a textbook: http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Price_Theory/PThy_ToC.html http://www.daviddfriedman.com/Academic/Price_Theory/PThy_ToC...
And I remind, it is not necessarily because "economic theory" must be right... it is because it is objectively true that you don't understand it. Perhaps if you do, you will find you opinion of it changes. (Even if you don't entirely agree with it, it would be weird if moving past a strawman didn't change your opinion.)
- gojomo 17y agoThe unnecessarily personal tone of this comment distracts from the substantive points. These statements only detract: Your understanding of the points you are arguing against is so terrible and flawed that you need to start over from scratch. ...betrays a profound misunderstanding... I commend to you a lot of time with a textbook... ...it is objectively true that you don't understand [economic theory]. The grandparent-poster reports having a degree in economics; his points may be be wrong, but a denigratory and lecturing tone won't convince him or others. (Edit: I initially flagged the 'idea... is such crap' line as problematic too, but then realized it was just a mirror of russell's own language. Still, it was shoddy name-calling by him initially; mirroring it back is understandable in response or to call attention to it, but doesn't lift the tone any.)