5 ms·
This is truly outrageous, in at least 2 ways: (1) that a modern government would ask its citizens to do this and (2) that the citizens who are doctors would go
by bediger4000 13y ago
This is truly outrageous, in at least 2 ways: (1) that a modern government would ask its citizens to do this and (2) that the citizens who are doctors would go along.
Name names: get the state boards to pull their licenses, because that's what these torturers deserve.
This is also a punishment worse than the crime, by the way.
- andrewcooke 13y agoThis is also a punishment worse than the crime no, no it's not. [edit: to clarify, my reading of "this" is to "pull their licenses"; apparently everyone else is reading it otherwise....]
- gknoy 13y agoI am pretty sure that torturing someone is worse than someone suspected of being part of a terrorist organization. Suspected is the key word, as is "part of". We don't deliberately torture convicted murderers: we kill them in a way which we (correctly or not) believe to be humane. We shouldn't be torturing suspected (or convicted!) terrorists either.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- CamperBob2 13y agoThis is also a punishment worse than the crime, by the way. What do you mean?
- anigbrowl 13y agoHe means that what the torturers/enablers of torture did is worse than the crimes the detainees are alleged to have committed.
- baddox 13y ago> that a modern government would ask its citizens to do this Why do you think that a "modern" government would be any better in this department than "old" governments? Is there any evidence to support this, or do people just like to think that these days things are better?
- potatolicious 13y agoI read 'old' as 'middle ages old'. There was a time when torture was openly acknowledged as acceptable practice. At least nowadays it's widely recognized as a Bad Thing, even if governments are willing to engage in it under the radar.
- pstuart 13y agoWhich is supported by the administrations' insistence on calling it "enhanced interrogation". Newspeak FTW.
- baddox 13y agoI question whether torture is widely recognized as a bad thing. I'm pretty sure I have seen US politicians openly acknowledge that we should torture for national security matters. But even if we assume that, the question remains: why should people believe that torture is less widespread than it was in the Middle Ages?
- jlgreco 13y agoTo clarify, are you actually asking why should they, or why do they?
- dragonwriter 13y agoThe Convention Against Torture exists, and most extent countries (including the US) have ratified it, which seems to represent a fairly wide recognition that torture is a bad thing, even if politicians often will assert exceptions of convenience as to why the general rule should not apply to specific situations.