4 ms·
It seems to me like they should switch to Android with their own launcher and compete on hardware. The big fat margins of the past are long gone but I think th
by mistermann 13y ago
It seems to me like they should switch to Android with their own launcher and compete on hardware. The big fat margins of the past are long gone but I think there is a healthy niche here that they could sit in for quite some time.
- admax88q 13y agoI hope not. BB10 is a very nice operating system. I'd hate to see it go to waste. I find it much more responsive and snappy than Android.
- protomyth 13y agoSwitching to Android is just a death wish. They need to control the whole stack and cannot be beholden to someone who competes with them in messaging.
- Touche 13y agoHow has that strategy worked out for others in the same space?
- thrillgore 13y agoPretty well for Samsung. It hasn't for HTC, LG, Motorola...
- Touche 13y agoSamsung controls the whole stack?
- protomyth 13y agoHow has switching to Android worked out for anyone but Samsung?
- Touche 13y agoVaries from company to company, Sony's doing well, HTC's not. But they're all still in business.
- protomyth 13y agoSony's had one good Q with 2013 Q2 and most think its at the expense of HTC. If they continue to carve a market out of what HTC and LG had then maybe they are doing "good", but one good quarter doesn't make a trend.
- Touche 13y agoLG just had a good Q3. Then there are manufacturers like Xiaomi who are doing well. There's really only 2 manufacturers doing gangbusters, Apple and Samsung, everyone knows that. But outside of those two companies the only ones still around are those that licensed OSes, everyone who has tried going it alone is out of business or in the process of going out of business. Do you really dispute this?
- protomyth 13y agoSo, the only two companies doing well have pretty good control of their CPU and supply chain and only 1 is using Android. I think Samsung could switch to FireFox OS and not miss a beat. Android isn't the strong brand to most consumers.
- Touche 13y agoI thought you said they had to control "the whole stack"? You just meant the CPU? There we might actually agree, I think went you look at what has happened in the mobile landscape since smartphones became popular I think what you see if that the companies whose only business is making phones are the ones that have struggled the most. Those that had businesses which feed into smartphones have done better.
- dgregd 13y agoBecause they have a problem with the simplest thing, choosing good brand name. Among Android companies, Samsung was the first one with consistent brand strategy: Galaxy S1, S2, ... updated each year. It doesn't require IQ 160 to grasp this: good name and update each year. But for some reason HTC, each x months created new brand: Hero, Desire, don't remember, One, and the last one: One X/Mega f... I don't remember even after reading Engadget three times a week. LG tried to copy Samsung and changed the letter to G. So finally we have G1 and G2. Not bad, they are more consisted than HTC. Sony has letter Z but still doesn't know how to enumerate updates. The last model is Z1 and the previous was Z or Z Zero? I don't know. Blackberry also uses letter Z, and their last model is Z10? At least Google coined good brand name, Nexus. Nokia has Lumia series which are selling quite well.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- hrktb 13y agoThey already kind of have. You can make most android apps work on a Blackberry 10 by simple repackaging and resubmission to App World. They didn't go the whole way, but as protomyth says, losing the control on critical parts wouldn't help them further in the long term.
- killme 13y agoSad to see so many technical folks wanting Blackberry and Nokia to join the Android bandwagon. The mobile market needs more competition and diversity, not less, or it will end up like the PC market did. If you want an Android phone, there's an immense variety already out there. It's like recommending that Apple scrap OS X and ship Windows on their Macs.
- sspiff 13y agoWhile I agree that going Android would be bad for BB, and having more diversity would be good for the mobile space, I disagree that there is immense variety in the existing Android handsets. They're all more or less the same design: thin low-quality plastic slabs of touchscreen phones of varying sizes. Choice is even smaller if you want a decent/high end phone: those just tend to be big. There is no differentiation based on form factors any more, it's basically a game of me-too and playing it safe.
- Nelson69 13y agoI don't know that Android is a long term winning strategy for them but I could see them staying alive. Many people point to hardware features like the keyboard as things they love about Blackberry. The conventional wisdom may be wrong in this case. Conventionally, if you wanted to save them you'd look at what they do best, look at their very core best capability and you'd go all in with that and maybe find a winning partner for the other stuff. As an outsider, and maybe because I'm just a computer dork and see the world this way, Blackberry is either a handset company or they're a bbOS company. So I'd say, put the people's platform on their handsets or put their OS on Samsung and other handsets. The one thing about them putting Android on their handsets, it gives their fans access to their hardware and it gives their customers access to software. BB10 has the same problems Windows Phone has, it may be great but my favorite apps aren't on it. How much better does the platform have to be to get over the missing apps? I hope they survive and come up with a plan. I don't see them ever being as big or profitable as they once were though.